(Stroke. 1995;26:950-955.)
© 1995 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Department of Neurology, University of Ulsan, Asan Medical Center, Seoul, South Korea.
Correspondence to Jong S. Kim, MD, Department of Neurology, Asan Medical Center, Song-Pa, PO Box 145, Seoul 138-600, South Korea.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods We studied the clinical features of 37 patients with acute infarcts that mainly involved the base of the pons and correlated the clinical syndromes with the radiological findings.
Results The clinical presentations included pure motor hemiparesis (PMH) in 17, sensorimotor stroke in 3, ataxic hemiparesis (AH) in 4, and dysarthriaclumsy hand (DA-CH) syndrome in 6 patients. Variants of AH included 1 patient with dysarthria-hemiataxia and 2 with quadrataxic hemiparesis, and in 4 patients dysarthriafacial paresis syndrome was considered a variant of DA-CH syndrome. Hypertension was the single most common and important risk factor, and the pathogenetic mechanisms of ischemia were likely to be small arterial (lacunar) occlusion or basilar atheromatous branch occlusion in most of the patients. Our clinical-radiological correlation study suggested that large lesions involving the paramedian caudal or middle pons correlate with severe hemiparesis (PMH), whereas lesions of similar size located in the paramedian rostral pons tended to produce DA-CH syndrome. Lesions producing AH were located variously but tended to spare the pyramidal tracts. The prognosis of these patients is fair or good, although residual hemiparesis remained in patients with initially severe hemiparesis.
Conclusions Our data suggest that the various lacunar syndromes that follow pontine base infarcts reflect the balance of the involvement of the corticospinal, corticopontocerebellar, and corticobulbar tracts. Analysis of radiological findings aids in determining the clinical-anatomic correlation in patients with pontine base infarction.
Key Words: cerebral infarction diagnostic imaging lacunar infarction pons
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The clinical syndromes were classified as PMH, SMS, AH, DA-CH, and
their variants according to previous
descriptions.1 7 17 20 In the first two groups, motor
weakness of the proximal part of the limbs was graded in five
categories (0, no contraction; 1, flicker or trace of contraction; 2,
active movement possible only with gravity eliminated; 3, active
movement against gravity but not resistance; 4, active movement against
resistance and gravity; and 5, normal power).21 When the
grade was different between the arm and leg, that of the arm was used
in this study. Dysarthria and facial paresis were graded as follows:
-, none; +, mild; and ++, moderate to marked (Fig 1
). AH and DA-CH
were defined as follows: AH, patients with obvious cerebellar ataxia
and hemiparesis mild (grade IV) enough to perform reliable cerebellar
function tests; DA-CH, clumsy limbs (muscle strength greater than grade
IV) with relatively severe dysarthria.
|
MRI was performed with the use of a 1.5 T-superconducting magnet (GE). An axial T2-weighted (repetition time [TR], 2500 milliseconds; echo time [TE], 80 milliseconds) scan was performed in a horizontal plane at 5- or 6-mm intervals. T1-weighted (TR, 600 milliseconds; TE, 20 milliseconds) axial and sagittal images were also obtained. Evaluation of the lesions generally depended on T2-weighted axial cuts. The images were evaluated rostrocaudally22 as follows: the rostral pons was characterized by its relatively round shape with small, round-shaped aqueduct; the middle pons was characterized by its square-shaped fourth ventricle, large middle cerebellar peduncles, and silhouettes of trigeminal nerves; and the caudal pons was characterized by its shape similar to the middle pons but with images of the facial/acoustic nerves and grooves instead of trigeminal nerves. In 5 patients in whom only CT scan was performed, the morphology of the pons was used for the evaluation. Three patients (patients 1, 5, and 19) underwent angiogram, and 3 (patients 15, 17, and 20) underwent MR angiography. In 32 patients evaluated with MRI, vertebrobasilar artery flow void signals were examined with the use of T2- and T1-weighted images. The radiological evaluation was performed by one of the authors who was blind to the patients' clinical histories. The size of the lesion was defined as large when the value of the longest diameter of the lesion (or dominant lesion when the lesions were seen in more than one cut) multiplied by its longest intersecting line was greater than 2 cm2, as small when it was less than 1 cm2, and as medium when it was between these two.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Pure Motor or Sensorimotor Stroke (Fig 1
)
Seventeen patients had PMH, and 3 had hemiplegia plus mild sensory
(pinprick and vibration) dysfunction. Patient 2 had transient, burning
paresthesia on the right face. At the time of maximum severity, motor
weakness was severe (grade 0 to II) in 12, moderate (grade III) in 5,
and mild (grade IV) in 3. The weakness was equal between arm and leg in
11 and was more severe in the arm in 9 patients. Motor weakness was
usually more severe in the distal than the proximal part of the limbs.
The mode of onset was usually smoothly or stutteringly progressive for
several hours or days, and heparinization, used in all patients with
progressive hemiparesis, did not halt the progression. In some patients
with a sluggishly progressive onset, initial symptoms resembled those
of DA-CH or AH. Despite frequently severe hemiparesis, dysarthria and
facial paresis were often mild or even absent in some patients (Fig 1
).
Dysarthria was moderate to marked in 8, and only 1 (patient 18) had
marked dysphagia that required a nasogastric tube for feeding. Four
patients (patients 13, 15, 17, and 18) showed distinct lingual paresis,
and patients 12 and 1 had contralateral palatal-lingual and
palatal-lingual- laryngeal hemiparesis, respectively.
The lesions were evaluated by MRI in 15 and by CT in 5 patients. They were situated in the caudal pons in 5, middle pons in 6, rostral pons in 1, and middle and rostral pons in 8 patients. The 12 patients with severe limb weakness had large lesions in 10, a medium-sized lesion in 1, and a small lesion in 1. All 3 patients with mild hemiparesis had small lesions.
Ataxic Hemiparesis and Its Variants (Fig 2
)
Four patients had AH, 2 of whom also had transient sensory
symptoms. Two (patients 25 and 26) showed AH and additional limb ataxia
on the side ipsilateral to the lesions, which was worse in the leg.
They had marked gait difficulty due to bilateral lower limb ataxia and
hemiparesis and were designated as having quadrataxic hemiparesis. One
(patient 27) showed dysarthria and hemiataxia but without hemiparesis
or hemihypesthesia and was designated as having
dysarthria-hemiataxia.
The lesions were evaluated with the use of MRI in all patients. The location was variable: caudal pons in 1, middle pons in 2, rostral pons in 1, caudal and middle pons in 1, and middle and rostral pons in 2 patients. Two had large infarcts: 1 in the middle pons and 1 in the rostral pons. Four had medium-sized and 1 had small lesions. In 4 (patients 22, 23, 25, and 27), the lesions were located relatively laterally.
DysarthriaClumsy Hand Syndrome and Its Variants (Fig 3
)
Six patients had DA-CH syndrome, 1 of whom had transient
hemisensory symptoms. Three patients had dysarthria and facial paresis
without limb involvement, and 1 presented with isolated dysarthria.
All the lesions were evaluated with the use of MRI. Seven patients had
lesions in the paramedian rostral pons, which were large in 5 and small
in 2. One had a medium-sized lesion involving the middle and rostral
pons, and 1 had a medium sized mid-pontine lesion.
Other Clinical Features and Follow-up Findings
Patients 8 and 11 with PMH had sixth nerve palsy. Patients 24 and
32 presented with transient uncontrollable laughter, and patient 26
had excessive crying followed by inappropriate smiling. Patient 17
became depressed and had a suicidal idea, while patient 28 showed
transient psychotic behavior. The patients were followed up for 1 to 47
(mean, 9) months. All survived the acute stage of stroke and improved
gradually except patients 6 and 18, who remained bedridden. Patient 25
had a recurrent infarct in the corona radiata in 2 months. All others
were able to walk, although patient 8 required assistance. The patients
with initially severe limb weakness had persistent hemiparesis of
variable degree. Seven patients manifested ataxia in the hemiparetic
limb as their motor strength improved.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Spectrum of Clinical Syndromes
In patients with PMH, the motor weakness was usually progressive
and unresponsive to anticoagulation. The progressive mode of onset and
unresponsiveness to anticoagulation were previously described in
patients with lacunar stroke.30 31 32 The weakness tended to
be more marked in the upper than lower extremity and in distal (hand or
foot) than proximal parts of the limbs. These features are in
accordance with the previous studies with pontine
infarction,6 33 although dominant leg weakness was also
reported.6 34 In agreement with previous studies with
unilateral brain stem infarction,6 33 35 36 the prognosis
was relatively good in our series. However, some degree of motor
weakness remained in patients with initially severe hemiparesis.
Despite frequently severe limb weakness, facial paresis and dysarthria
were often mild or even absent in occasional cases. Distinct lingual,
palatal-lingual, or palatal-lingual-laryngeal hemipareses were observed
in 6 patients, which resembled the clinical features of so-called
capsular genu syndrome.37
In the literature, the differentiation between AH and DA-CH has not always been clear. Fisher20 stated that the latter may be a variant of the former. After analyzing 337 patients with lacunar stroke, Chamorro et al38 stated that syndromes of AH and DA-CH may be viewed as one entity. Glass et al19 reported that DA-CH seen in their 6 patients with pontine infarction had characteristics of cerebellar ataxia and suggested that some of the cases previously reported as having AH should be reclassified as having DA-CH syndrome. However, Fisher's17 original description of DA-CH referred to "clumsiness, awkwardness, slowness of fine manipulations, wavering ataxia on finger to nose test which is not clearly cerebellar in type." Therefore, in our study patients with obvious ataxia and definitive weakness (grade IV) were classified as having AH.
Several cases described here deserve attention. Patient 27 showed dysarthria and hemiataxia but without hemiparesis or hemihypesthesia. A few patients with similar symptoms were previously described: dysarthriafacial paresishemiataxia (second cases of Glass et al19 and Hopf et al39 ) and isolated hemiataxia (second case of Nabatame et al14 ). They were variously classified as AH,14 DA-CH,19 and pontine supranuclear facial palsy.39 However, cerebellar hemiataxia without hemiparesis is distinguished from the original description of AH40 and may be described as dysarthria-hemiataxia syndrome as a variant of AH. Hemiataxia without hemiparesis has also been described in patients with thalamic stroke, usually with accompanying sensory symptoms,41 42 although hemiataxia without sensory dysfunction can also be caused by thalamic43 or capsular44 lesions.
We found 2 patients with AH and additional ataxia on the side ipsilateral to the lesion. Van Gijn and Vermeulen45 described bilateral AH (ataxic tetraplegia) due to recurrent pontine infarctions. Recent reports also described bilateral ataxia following unilateral pontine lesions,25 35 46 which may be attributable to an involvement of the crossing corticopontocerebellar tracts.46 Our patients had ataxia that was more marked in the lower extremities and subjectively felt a sense of heaviness or weakness in both legs. The marked gait difficulty seen in these patients was reminiscent of astasia or gait ataxia caused by unilateral thalamic47 or midbrain48 49 strokes.
We examined 6 patients with DA-CH syndrome. We also observed 3 patients with dysarthria and facial paresis and 1 with dysarthria only but without involvement of the limbs. This clinical feature may be designated as dysarthriafacial paresis syndrome as a variant of DA-CH.50 Pure dysarthria or dysarthriafacial paresis syndrome has previously been reported to be produced by capsularcorona radiata, cortical, or pontine strokes.50 51 52 53 54
Clinical-Radiological Correlation
In the patients with PMH or SMS, the lesions causing severe
hemiparesis were usually large and widely involved the ventral surface
of the paramedian caudal or middle pons (patients 1, 4, 6, 7, 8, 10,
14, and 15), whereas small, median lesions (patients 2, 11, and 12)
correlated with mild limb weakness. However, patients without or with
minimal limb weakness (DA-CH and its variants) frequently had large
lesions in the paramedian rostral pons (patients 28 through 30 and 33
through 35). The lack of correlation between the size of lesion and the
degree of hemiparesis was noted by previous authors,33 55
who speculated that a large part of the infarct seen on MRI may
implicate edema rather than destructive lesions. This assumption may be
supported by an observation that a large pontine infarct was
significantly reduced in size on follow-up MRI.33 However,
this is hardly a satisfactory explanation given our observation that
the paramedian lesions at the level of the caudal or middle pons large
enough to cause severe hemiparesis did not produce a corresponding
degree of symptoms when they are located in the rostral pons.
Therefore, other explanations should be considered. First, the
corticospinal tracts in the midbrain are located in the middle of the
cerebral peduncle as compact bundles. In the upper pons, however, they
run along with the corticopontine fibers in a loosely dispersed manner
within abundant and heavily traversing nonpyramidal
fibers.20 Therefore, the impact on the
pyramidal tracts by a focal infarct in the upper pons may
not be as severe as in the lower pons, where pyramidal
fibers again become compact. Second and more importantly, the
corticospinal tracts are situated in the dorsolateral part of the
pontine base at the level of the upper pons and are converged into the
anteromedial surface of the upper medulla to form compact
bundles.56 Therefore, the pontine base lesions, usually
situated in the paramedian-ventral area, may more effectively damage
the corticospinal tracts when they are located in the lower rather than
upper part of the pons (Fig 4
). This topographic
characteristic may explain why the lesions located (patients 13 and 17)
or extending (patient 18) into the lateral part of the upper pons
produced relatively more severe motor weakness (PMH) than paramedian
lesions (DA-CH).
|
Also noteworthy was that dysarthria was usually more marked in
patients with upper pontine lesions (patients 5, 8, 13, 16 through 18,
and 20 with PMH and patients with DA-CH syndrome) compared with the
patients with severe hemiparesis (PMH) without upper pontine lesions
(patients 3, 4, 9, 10, 14, and 15). In the midbrain and upper pons, the
corticobulbar tracts are located medial to the corticospinal
fibers.57 At the pontine level, there are multiple
connections between both corticobulbar tracts except for the fibers
subserving the lower facial muscles.58 59 The presence of
these connections or aberrant fibers at multiple levels of the pons may
explain the paucity or transience of palatal and lingual weakness in
patients with unilateral strokes. The aberrant fibers of the nucleus
ambiguus or hypoglossal nuclei are given off at the level of the upper
pons, although they are reinforced by the bulbopontine fibers emerging
at the level of the pontomedullary junction.60 The rostral
pontine lesions therefore may effectively involve the multiple crossing
fibers as well as the medial part of the corticospinal tracts (Fig 4
),
thus easily producing bulbar symptoms.
Fisher20 stated that pontine base infarctions at the junction of the upper one third and inferior two thirds may produce AH. Bogousslavsky et al13 and Nabatame et al,14 after analyzing MRI findings of their patients with AH, found that the lesions were located in the dorsomedial area, sparing the ventral part. Our patients with AH showed lesions in various areas, suggesting that in the pontine base, pontocerebellar fibers are widespread and may easily be involved. The disappearance and reappearance of limb ataxia after the progression or recovery of severe motor weakness in some of the patients with PMH suggested that it is the balance of the involvement of the pyramidal and pontocerebellar tracts that determines the clinical subtypes. Relatively laterally (patients 17, 18, 20, and 22) or far ventrally (patients 20 and 21) situated midcaudal pontine lesions may have involved the corticospinal tracts less markedly, thus producing AH or dysarthria-hemiataxia syndrome. The rostral pontine lesions of patients 23 and 24 were similar in location to that producing DA-CH, further suggesting that clinical differentiation of DA-CH and AH may not be absolute. The lesions of patients 25 and 26 producing bilateral ataxia and marked gait disturbance might have predominantly involved pontovermis or fastigiopontine fibers, both of which are bilaterally connected between the pons and the cerebellar vermis.61
Finally, 5 patients presented with transient pathological crying, laughter, depression, or psychotic behaviors. Pathological crying or laughter, classically seen in patients with bilateral cerebral lesions as a component of pseudobulbar palsy,62 63 is known to occur in patients with unilateral strokes.64 Transient crying,65 uncontrollable laughter,25 mania,66 or psychotic symptoms67 were also reported in patients with brain stem stroke. Andersen et al68 suggested that some of these symptoms may be attributed to altered serotonin neurotransmission. Presumably, the pontine serotonergic center or the superior projection from this structure might have been involved in the above 5 patients.
Note: Some of the patients in this study were included in our previous articles.50 69
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received January 25, 1995; revision received March 14, 1995; accepted March 14, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. S. Kim and J. Kim Pure midbrain infarction: Clinical, radiologic, and pathophysiologic findings Neurology, April 12, 2005; 64(7): 1227 - 1232. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. D. Schmahmann, R. Ko, and J. MacMore The human basis pontis: motor syndromes and topographic organization Brain, June 1, 2004; 127(6): 1269 - 1291. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A Arboix, Y Bell, L Garcia-Eroles, J Massons, E Comes, M Balcells, and C Targa Clinical study of 35 patients with dysarthria-clumsy hand syndrome J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry, February 1, 2004; 75(2): 231 - 234. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Moncayo, G. Devuyst, G. Van Melle, and J. Bogousslavsky Coexisting Causes of Ischemic Stroke Arch Neurol, August 1, 2000; 57(8): 1139 - 1144. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Hartmann, E. S. Conolly, D. H. Duong, C. J. Prestigiacomo, S. Joshi, J. P. Mohr, and H. Mast Dysarthria during basilar artery balloon occlusion Neurology, July 1, 1999; 53(2): 421 - 421. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
S. Kataoka, A. Hori, T. Shirakawa, and G. Hirose Paramedian Pontine Infarction : Neurological/Topographical Correlation Stroke, April 1, 1997; 28(4): 809 - 815. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
J. S. Kim, H. G. Kim, and C. S. Chung Medial Medullary Syndrome : Report of 18 New Patients and a Review of the Literature Stroke, September 1, 1995; 26(9): 1548 - 1552. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Stroke Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1995 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |