| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
(Stroke. 1995;26:1620-1626.)
© 1995 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Department of Neurosurgery, Juntendo University Izunagaoka Hospital, Shizuoka, Japan.
Correspondence to Kentaro Mori, Department of Neurosurgery, Juntendo University Izunagaoka Hospital, 1129 Nagaoka Izunagaoka-cho, Tagata-gun, Shizuoka 410-22, Japan.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods Ninety-eight patients who underwent early craniotomy for aneurysm clipping surgery after SAH were studied. Fifty-one patients (52.0%) developed symptomatic vasospasm. The hematocrit level and red blood cell aggregability were measured daily from day 1 to day 14, whereas the circulating blood volume and cerebral blood flow were measured periodically. Cardiac output and pulmonary capillary wedge pressure were also measured using a Swan-Ganz catheter.
Results The hematocrit level was decreased significantly to 29% to 32% by hypervolemic hemodilution therapy. Red blood cell aggregability increased until day 6 but was significantly reduced by therapy. Hypovolemia tended to develop after SAH. However, patients receiving hypervolemic hemodilution therapy became normovolemic to hypervolemic, with a significant increase of cardiac output and pulmonary capillary wedge pressure. At the onset of vasospasm, cerebral blood flow was significantly lower on the operated side than on the contralateral side, and it increased on both sides with therapy.
Conclusions Patients with SAH develop hypovolemia, hemodynamic depression, and increased red blood cell aggregability. Hypervolemic hemodilution therapy decreases hematocrit level and red cell aggregability while increasing cardiac output. Improvement of hemorheological and hemodynamic parameters by this therapy can reverse neurological deterioration due to cerebral vasospasm.
Key Words: erythrocyte aggregation hemodilution subarachnoid hemorrhage vasospasm
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Hypervolemic therapy (intravascular volume expansion therapy) and hemodilution therapy have been shown to be effective for reducing neurological deficits due to delayed cerebral vasospasm.3 4 5 6 7 Hypervolemic hemodilution therapy increases the blood volume and cardiac output and therefore theoretically improves the rheological properties of the cerebral circulation.
The purpose of the present study was to monitor hemorheological and hemodynamic parameters in patients with vasospasm after aneurysmal SAH and to assess how hypervolemic hemodilution therapy altered these factors.
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Hypervolemic hemodilution therapy was continued until the resolution of symptoms of vasospasm, usually after 5 to 7 days.
To monitor hemorheological parameters, the hematocrit level, hemoglobin concentration, and RBC aggregation rate were measured daily from days 1 through 14. The RBC aggregation rate was measured using a whole blood aggregometer (Nihon Kohden Corp)11 on the basis of changes in light transmittance due to rouleau formation by fresh heparinized whole blood in a vinyl tube. The optical density was recorded continuously during momentary forward movement and sudden cessation of movement of the blood in the tube to apply a shear force. The aggregation rate (K) was calculated as K=-10-1xln(L20-L10/L10-L0) where L0, L10, and L20 are the measured optical density at 0, 10, and 20 seconds after the destruction of rouleaux by the application of shear force.11
The circulating blood volume was measured periodically by the indicator dilution method using 99mTc-labeled human serum albumin diethylenetriaminepenta-acetic acid (99mTc-HSA-D, Nihon Medi-Physics, Co). The predicted blood volume was calculated using the height-cubed body mass formula of Nadler et al12 as revised by Fujita13 for the Japanese population: for men, predicted blood volume in liters equals 0.1682H3+0.05048W+0.4444 and for women, predicted blood volume equals 0.2502H3+0.06253W-0.6620, where H is height in meters and W is weight in kilograms. All patients were weighed daily on a bed scale.
Quantitative measurements of CBF were also periodically obtained by the external counting method using N-isopropyl-p-[123I]iodoamphetamine (123I-IMP, Nihon Medi-Physics Co). A two-head, calibrated lead collimator detector equipped with two-channel renograms (Shimazu Corp) was specially designed to permit continuous determination of brain tissue activity. The heads of the collimator were symmetrically positioned over the coronal sutures 5 cm from the midline, and CBF was calculated from the 123I activity of the arterial blood and brain tissue. The CBF value of a normal population determined at this institution was 61.0±7.8 mL/100 g per minute (mean±SD, n=20).14
To assess the hemodynamic state and prevent pulmonary edema, a Swan-Ganz catheter (Baxter Healthcare Corp) was positioned via a subclavian approach in the patients with symptomatic vasospasm to monitor the pulmonary artery pressure and PCWP. The cardiac output and cardiac index were periodically measured by the thermodilution method using cold physiological saline. The PCWP was maintained at or below 18 mm Hg to prevent cardiopulmonary complications.5
Statistical Methods
Results were analyzed for statistical significance
using Student's t test, Fisher's exact
test,15 Scheffé's multiple comparison
test,16 and Dunnett's multiple comparison
test,17 with P<.05 being considered
significant. Data are represented as mean±SEM.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Hematocrit Level
In the patients without symptomatic vasospasm,
hematocrit level did not change throughout the observation period (Fig 1
). In the patients with symptomatic
vasospasm, hematocrit level did not change significantly on days
1 to 6, but hypervolemic therapy caused a significant decrease
(P<.05) (Fig 1
).
|
Red Blood Cell Aggregation Rate
On days 4 to 6 in the patients without vasospasm and on days 4 and
6 in the patients with vasospasm (Fig 2
), the RBC
aggregation rate was significantly higher than on day 1
(P<.05). The aggregation rate was also slightly higher in
the patients with vasospasm than in those without it on days 1 to 6.
Hypervolemic hemodilution therapy significantly reduced the RBC
aggregation rate on days 7 to 10 compared with days 4 to 6
(P<.001). These results clearly demonstrate that the RBC
aggregation rate increases gradually after SAH and that hypervolemic
hemodilution therapy significantly decreases RBC aggregation.
|
Circulating Blood Volume
The circulating blood volume was measured four times (ie, 2 or 3
days after clipping surgery, on day 5 to 7 at the onset of vasospasm in
the vasospasm group, on day 10 to 14 during hypervolemic hemodilution
therapy in the vasospasm group, and on the day of discharge). The
measured volume is shown plotted against the predicted blood volume in
Fig 3
. Data points above a 45°-slope regression line
indicate a hypervolemic state, and points below the line indicate a
hypovolemic state. At 2 to 3 days, most of the patients were
approximately normovolemic. However, on days 5 to 7 after SAH, most of
the patients tended to be hypovolemic according to our criteria. At the
third measurement, most patients receiving hypervolemic therapy were
normovolemic to hypervolemic by our criteria, and most patients without
such therapy were hypovolemic. The difference between the two groups
was statistically significant (P<.01). On the day of
discharge, patients in both groups were normovolemic.
|
Hemodynamic Data
The hemodynamic data obtained before and after
hypervolemic hemodilution therapy are presented in Table 2
. At the onset of symptomatic vasospasm,
the cardiac output was 4.3±0.4 L/min and the cardiac index was
2.8±0.3 L/min per square meter, both within the lower limit of the
normal range.18 The PCWP was 7.5±1.3 mm Hg, and this was
slightly low.18 Hypervolemic hemodilution therapy
caused all three parameters to increase significantly,
although they remained within normal limits. During therapy, the PCWP
was 11.0±1.2 mm Hg. The systolic blood pressure increased by about 20
mm Hg during therapy but remained below 180 mm Hg in all
patients.
|
Cerebral Blood Flow
CBF measurement was performed at the time of circulating blood
volume measurement, and the data are shown in Fig 4
. At
the first CBF measurement in the patients with symptomatic
vasospasm, blood flow on the operated side (54±2.8 mL/100 g per
minute, mean±SE) was slightly lower than on the contralateral side
(55±2.6 mL/100 g per minute), but the difference was not significant.
On the day that vasospasm developed, CBF on the operated side decreased
significantly (46±1.4 mL/100 g per minute) in comparison with the
nonoperated side (52±2.5 mL/100 g per minute) (P<.01).
During hypervolemic hemodilution therapy, CBF returned to baseline on
both sides. In the patients without symptomatic vasospasm,
CBF did not change significantly throughout the observation period. The
patients with symptomatic vasospasm showed significantly
lower CBF than the patients without symptomatic vasospasm
even before the onset of their symptoms (P<.01).
|
Overall Outcome
The primary end point for the study was the number of patients
achieving a good recovery according to Allen's neurological outcome
score.19 Of the 98 patients who underwent early clipping
surgery, 51 (52.0%) developed symptomatic vasospasm. The
neurological grades on admission (Hunt-Hess8 ), at the
onset of vasospasm (Hunt-Hess), and at the end of hypervolemic
hemodilution therapy (Allen et al19 ) are illustrated in
Fig 5
. After hypervolemic hemodilution therapy, 29
patients (56.9%) were neurologically normal, 13 (25.5%) had mild or
moderate disability, and 9 patients (17.6%) died. Six of these
patients died of vasospasm in the acute stage, and the other 3 died of
pneumonia in the chronic stage. The admission Hunt-Hess grade of the 6
patients dying in the acute stage was grade II in two cases, grade III
in three cases, and grade IV in one case. Death or severe
disability (leading to death from pneumonia) resulted from vasospasm in
6.1% of all the patients with SAH. Two patients developed
pulmonary edema during hypervolemic hemodilution therapy, but
both responded well to diuretic therapy.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
At reduced driving pressures, blood flow is limited by the increase of
viscosity that occurs at low shear rates.25 Since RBC
aggregation is also shear-rate dependent, aggregation may be enhanced
in the cerebral microcirculation, especially in ischemic areas
where the shear rate is low.22 Wood et al23
demonstrated in dogs that the blood viscosity at low shear rates
decreases with an increase of total blood volume and plasma volume
after plasma infusion. It has also been shown that at lower shear
rates, erythrocyte aggregation plays the major role in determining
blood viscosity.26 Hasegawa27 reported that
hypercoagulability, platelet hyperactivity, and reduced RBC
deformability occurred with vasospasm in a canine model of SAH. Such
systemic changes of intravascular components could promote cerebral
ischemia through an increase of blood viscosity. Measurement of
the hematocrit level alone does not give a precise estimate of blood
viscosity,24 28 and monitoring of RBC aggregability is
also desirable. Tomita et al11 reported that the RBC
aggregation rate of whole blood varies linearly with the hematocrit at
values below 40%. The present study showed that hematocrit was
relatively stable for the first 5 days after aneurysm clipping,
but the RBC aggregation rate increased during this period. The RBC
aggregation rate was decreased by hypervolemic hemodilution therapy
both because of a decrease in hematocrit and by the direct effect of
the low-molecular-weight dextran, which reduces RBC aggregation,
reduces blood viscosity, and improves microcirculatory flow at low
shear rates.20 29 30 The cause of the increase in RBC
aggregability after SAH is not clear, but it may be related to changes
of plasma albumin, fibrinogen,
2-macroglobulin,
or RBC surface charge.31 SAH itself may alter the RBC
surface charge and other RBC membrane properties.
Maroon and Nelson6 reported that decrease of circulating blood volume and red cell mass in patients with SAH. Pritz et al7 also found a decrease of circulating blood volume at the time of symptomatic vasospasm. Possible causes of the hypovolemia in patients with SAH include bedrest with supine diuresis and pooling in the peripheral vascular bed, negative nitrogen balance, decreased erythropoiesis, iatrogenic blood loss, dehydrating agents (eg, mannitol and glycerol), and hyponatremia.6
Evidence has accumulated that patients with cerebral vasospasm show good recovery from ischemic symptoms after intravascular volume expansion therapy.3 4 6 7
In the present study, the circulating blood volume progressively decreased after aneurysm clipping surgery, whereas the patients became normovolemic or hypervolemic after hypervolemic hemodilution therapy. CBF in the ischemic brain is both pressure and volume dependent because cerebral autoregulation is impaired, so monitoring circulating blood volume in patients with SAH can be useful for the prevention and treatment of cerebral vasospasm.32
There are several reports on the usefulness of hypertensive therapy for cerebral vasospasm.4 33 34 Dopamine-induced hypertension improves CBF in the ischemic region in patients with SAH, but the CBF response to dopamine in the nonischemic region is variable.35 In the present study, systemic blood pressure was increased by about 20 mm Hg without vasopressor agents after hypervolemic hemodilution therapy.
The effect of increasing cardiac output in patients with cerebral vasospasm is still controversial. Several authors have reported the reversal of ischemic neurological signs after an increase of the cardiac output.36 37 Pritz et al7 found improvement of neurological deficits due to cerebral vasospasm when the cardiac output was increased without raising arterial pressure. Davis and Sundt38 showed a significant decrease of cerebral blood flow in cats when cardiac output was decreased by the withdrawal of blood or the administration of propranolol, even though arterial pressure remained essentially constant. However, Wood et al39 reported that elevation of the total blood volume without hemodilution raised the cardiac output but did not improve CBF in either ischemic or normal brain regions in dogs. In the present series, the patients had a low PCWP, suggesting a hypovolemic state, and the mean cardiac output and cardiac index were at the lower limit of normal or below normal. Thus, our patients with SAH were not only hypovolemic but also hemodynamically depressed. Hypervolemic hemodilution therapy improved all of these parameters. A PCWP of 12 to 14 mm Hg is reported to be associated with maximum cardiac performance,40 and the PCWP was in this range after hypervolemic hemodilution therapy.
In the present study, the CBF of all the patients on days 2 to 4 was lower than the control value determined in normal individuals. Before the onset of symptomatic vasospasm, the CBF was even lower than in patients who did not develop vasospasm. In agreement with these findings, Knuckey et al10 reported that during the first week after SAH, patients who developed cerebral ischemia had a significantly lower CBF than patients who did not. Early CBF measurements are reported to be of value in detecting delayed cerebral vasospasm.10 41 42 At the onset of symptomatic vasospasm, we found that the CBF on the operated side was significantly lower than that on the contralateral side, whereas hypervolemic hemodilution therapy caused a bilateral increase of CBF. These data demonstrated that hypervolemic hemodilution therapy improved the blood supply to the brain during cerebral vasospasm.
The 52% symptomatic vasospasm rate in the present series was high. There have been several reports about mechanical factors during aneurysm clipping surgery causing vasospasm.43 Mishima et al44 reported that the incidence of symptomatic vasospasm is higher on the operated side after early clipping surgery; all the patients in our series had early surgery, so this might have contributed to the high incidence of symptomatic vasospasm.
With respect to outcome, our mortality and severe disability rates due to cerebral vasospasm (6.1%) were lower than those in the international cooperative study on standard therapy reported by Kassel and Torner45 (16%) and the nimodipine study reported by Allen et al19 (13.3%). Results similar to ours have been achieved with hypervolemic hemodilution and arterial hypertension therapy by Awad et al3 and with high-dose nicardipine by Haley et al.46 Thus, our hypervolemic hemodilution therapy protocol seems to be reasonably effective in preventing delayed neurological deficits after cerebral vasospasm.
Intravenous infusion of 10% glycerol was routinely used in all our patients. Meyer et al47 48 have reported that 10% glycerol decreases the intracranial pressure and increases CBF after acute cerebral infarction, and this is the basis for our routine use of glycerol after aneurysm clipping surgery. Since both groups of patients received glycerol, it should not have influenced our results. Nimodipine was not used in this study because it is not available in Japan, and we wanted to assess the hemodynamic state after SAH without calcium antagonists. However, it is clear that nimodipine is effective for treating cerebral vasospasm.19 Combined use of hypervolemic hemodilution therapy and another calcium antagonist (nicardipine) for cerebral vasospasm is now under investigation at our institution.
In this study, we followed the hemorheological and hemodynamic state in patients with aneurysmal SAH and assessed how hypervolemic hemodilution therapy improved these factors during cerebral vasospasm. We found that patients with SAH were hypovolemic and hemodynamically depressed with increased RBC aggregability. All of these factors are unfavorable to the cerebral circulation, especially in the ischemic region affected by cerebral vasospasm. Hypervolemic hemodilution therapy decreased the hematocrit level and RBC aggregation rate while increasing systemic blood pressure and cardiac output. The improvement of hemodynamics combined with hypertension increased the perfusion pressure and improved CBF, whereas the optimal hematocrit level improved oxygen transport capacity. The decrease of RBC aggregation and hematocrit led to a decrease in blood viscosity and presumably improved blood flow in the microcirculation at low shear rates.
We conclude that the improvement of hemorheological and hemodynamic parameters induced by hypervolemic hemodilution therapy is effective in reversing progressive neurological deterioration due to cerebral vasospasm.
Cerebral vasospasm after SAH is caused by multiple factors.43 We believe that hypervolemic hemodilution therapy combined with other therapies, such as nimodipine,46 cisternal irrigation,49 and percutaneous transluminal angioplasty,50 may improve the mortality and morbidity due to SAH.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received February 24, 1995; revision received April 27, 1995; accepted May 11, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
T. Mutoh, K. Kazumata, M. Ajiki, S. Ushikoshi, and S. Terasaka Goal-Directed Fluid Management by Bedside Transpulmonary Hemodynamic Monitoring After Subarachnoid Hemorrhage * Supplemental Material Stroke, December 1, 2007; 38(12): 3218 - 3224. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. Liu, V. Soppi, T. Mustonen, M. Kononen, T. Koivisto, A. Koskela, J. Rinne, and R. L. Vanninen Subarachnoid Hemorrhage in the Subacute Stage: Elevated Apparent Diffusion Coefficient in Normal-appearing Brain Tissue after Treatment Radiology, December 19, 2006; (2006) 2422051698. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
L. Belayev, Y. Liu, W. Zhao, R. Busto, and M. D. Ginsberg Human Albumin Therapy of Acute Ischemic Stroke : Marked Neuroprotective Efficacy at Moderate Doses and With a Broad Therapeutic Window Stroke, February 1, 2001; 32(2): 553 - 560. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Lennihan, S. A. Mayer, M. E. Fink, A. Beckford, M. C. Paik, H. Zhang, Y.-C. Wu, L. M. Klebanoff, E. C. Raps, and R. A. Solomon Effect of Hypervolemic Therapy on Cerebral Blood Flow After Subarachnoid Hemorrhage : A Randomized Controlled Trial Stroke, February 1, 2000; 31(2): 383 - 391. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. A. Mayer, J. Lin, S. Homma, R. A. Solomon, L. Lennihan, D. Sherman, M. E. Fink, A. Beckford, and L. M. Klebanoff Myocardial Injury and Left Ventricular Performance After Subarachnoid Hemorrhage Stroke, April 1, 1999; 30(4): 780 - 786. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Stroke Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1995 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |