(Stroke. 1997;28:1783-1788.)
© 1997 American Heart Association, Inc.
Articles |
From the Center for Molecular and Vascular Biology, University of Leuven, Belgium.
Correspondence to Désiré Collen, MD, PhD, Center for Molecular and Vascular Biology, University of Leuven, Campus Gasthuisberg, O & N, Herestraat 49, B-3000 Leuven, Belgium. E-mail Desire.Collen{at}med.kuleuven.ac.be
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods Groups of 5 to 12 rabbits were given intravenous saline or heparin and aspirin with, in addition, either Sak (1 or 2 mg/kg infused over 30 minutes or 2 mg/kg injected over 1 minute) or rTPA (3 or 6 mg/kg infused over 30 minutes or 6 mg/kg injected over 1 minute). Infusions were started 15 minutes after selective injection of standardized 125I-fibrin labeled rabbit plasma clots into the internal carotid artery.
Results Mean clot lysis over 60 minutes increased from 3.8% after saline to between 27% and 44% after Sak regimens (P=.0001 versus control) and to between 15% and 34% after rTPA regimens (P=.0001). Median volume of the ischemic lesion at 5 hours decreased from 190 mm3 after saline to between 11 and 17 mm3 after Sak (P=.02) and to between 0.5 to 54 mm3 after rTPA (P=.04). Mean neurological impairment at 5 hours (on a scale of 0 to 3) decreased from 2.3 after saline to between 1.3 to 1.6 after Sak (P=.003) and to between 1.1 to 1.9 after rTPA (P=.02). At the highest doses used, fibrinogen depletion was marginal with Sak but total with rTPA. Marked prolongation of ear puncture and cuticle bleeding times was only observed after bolus administration of rTPA.
Conclusions In the present rabbit model of embolic stroke, Sak was significantly more fibrin-specific than rTPA and at least as effective in lysing arterial emboli and limiting ischemia and neurological impairment.
Key Words: thrombolytic therapy cerebral ischemia rabbits animal models
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Thrombolytic therapy for ischemic stroke is based on the premise that timely recanalization of arteries supplying the brain may salvage "the ischemic penumbra,"6 the hypoperfused but potentially viable zone adjacent to the central ischemic area, limit infarct size, and improve functional recovery and survival. This hypothesis is reminiscent of the "open-artery theory" postulated for coronary thrombolysis.7 Yet, current clinical experience suggests that the "time window of opportunity" may be smaller for cerebrovascular than for coronary thrombolysis.
Recombinant Sak is a highly fibrin-selective profibrinolytic agent that has shown promise for coronary and peripheral arterial thrombolysis.8 9 10 11 12 The present study was designed to study the relation between thrombolytic activity, infarct size, and neurological status and, more specifically, to compare the thrombolytic potency and fibrin specificity of Sak and rTPA in a rabbit embolic stroke model.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Rabbit Embolic Stroke Model
The animal experiments were conducted according to the guiding
principles of the American Physiological Society
and the International Committee on Thrombosis and
Haemostasis.13
Sixty-two New Zealand White rabbits of either sex, weighing 2.5 to 3.5 kg, were premedicated with an intramuscular injection of 20 mg xylazine (Rompun 2%, Bayer) and 50 mg ketamin (Ketalin, Apharmo). A 0.8-mm cannula (Insyte-W, Becton-Dickinson) was inserted into the right marginal ear vein for maintenance anesthesia with sodium pentobarbital (Nembutal, Sanofi), 5 to 10 mg as needed, and for infusion of study medication. A 1.3-mm cannula (Insyte-W) was placed in the right femoral artery for blood sampling and blood pressure recording. A heating pad was applied to maintain body temperature. The right carotid artery bifurcation was exposed via a midline incision, all minor branches of the right common carotid artery were ligated or cauterized, the right internal carotid artery was identified and its extracranial part exposed, and the main branches of the external carotid artery were ligated. Internal and common carotid arteries were then temporarily clamped with vessel clips. The 4F catheter containing the four 3-mm clots was inserted via the bifurcation of the external carotid artery, with its tip into the ostium of the internal carotid artery. After removal of the vessel clip from the internal carotid artery, the clots were injected selectively and briskly into the internal carotid artery, while the rabbit's reaction was noted. After removal of the 4F catheter, the external carotid artery was closed. Subsequently, the common carotid artery was reopened, thus restoring blood flow toward the internal carotid artery.
The time course of clot lysis was monitored continuously for 75 minutes by external gamma counting, using a 3x0.5-inch sodium iodide/thallium crystal (Bicron), positioned over the rabbit's skull, and connected to a dedicated Canberra-S100 system (Canberra-Packard). Thereafter the operation wounds were closed and the rabbits were allowed to recover from anesthesia.
Study Drugs
Sak (natural variant Sak42D) was produced, purified, and
characterized as described elsewhere.14 rTPA (alteplase,
Activase) was a kind gift from Genentech, South San Francisco, Calif.
Heparin was purchased from Novo Nordisk, and aspirin for
intravenous use (Aspegic, lysine acetyl salicylic acid, in
vials containing 0.9 g, corresponding to 0.5 g acetyl
salicylic acid) was obtained from Synthelabo Benelux.
Fifteen minutes after embolization, infusions were started via the
right marginal ear vein. Rabbits were randomly allocated to seven
groups: intravenous infusions over 30 minutes starting with
a 10% bolus, of saline, Sak (1 mg/kg or 2 mg/kg), or
rTPA (3 mg/kg or 6 mg/kg) or bolus infusions over 1
minute of Sak (2 mg/kg) or rTPA (6 mg/kg) (Table 1
). Sak and rTPA were diluted in
physiological saline up to 16.5 mL. The lower dose
of rTPA is in the range of the optimal dose (3.3 mg/kg over 30
minutes) derived from previous dose-finding studies in rabbit embolic
stroke models.15 The corresponding doses of Sak were
determined with the relative molecular weights of rTPA
(Mr, 70 000) and Sak
(Mr, 15 500) and the equivalence for
coronary thrombolysis of 100 mg rTPA versus 30
mg Sak12 in mind.
|
All rabbits allocated to rTPA or Sak were pretreated with 30 mg/kg aspirin, administered after baseline bleeding time determination, and received conjunctive heparin. Heparin was started together with the thrombolytic agent, as a 200 IU/kg bolus, followed by a 100 IU/kg infusion in saline up to 15 mL, for 1 hour.
Outcome Measures
Clot Lysis
Clot lysis was quantitated as the decrease in externally
recorded cranial radioactivity count over 60 minutes following
study drug initiation and expressed as percent lysis. Additionally, the
increase in blood radioactivity was determined on samples taken one
minute after embolization and 75 minutes thereafter.
Clinical Outcome
Five hours after embolization the rabbits were scored clinically
as: 0, no neurological impairment; 1, mild to moderate neurological
impairment; 2, severe neurological impairment (including hemiparesis,
persistent sopor, circling behavior); or 3, death within 5 hours of
embolization. This semiquantitative classification scheme
represents a modification of the score introduced by Bederson
et al in a rat middle cerebral artery occlusion model.16
Five hours after the insult, rabbits with no or minimal deficit were
well awake and responsive.
Ischemic Lesion
After clinical scoring, the animals were euthanized and the
brains were removed. The residual radioactivities of the brain and of
the decerebrated skull were measured separately by external gamma
counting. Rabbits were only included for further analysis if
the former exceeded the latter. This precaution was taken in view of
the variability of the rabbit's extracranial
circulation17 18 and the ensuing risk of erroneous
extracranial deposition of emboli. Consequently, 9 rabbits (1 or 2 out
of each of the seven treatment groups) were excluded. The 85% success
rate (53 of 62 rabbits) for intracranial embolization equals that of
previous reports.17 The brains were then put in a 2% TTC
solution (Sigma) at 36°C for 30 minutes. After immersion for 5
minutes in ice water, the brains were cut in coronal slices of
approximately 3 mm. After macroscopic examination for
hemorrhage, the slices were once again put in 2% TTC at 36°C
for 1 hour and thereafter in 10% phosphate-buffered formalin for at
least 5 days. The TTC enzymatic tissue staining technique provides a
clear macroscopic distinction between infarcted (TTC-negative or
unstained) and noninfarcted (TTC-positive or crimson red)
areas19 20 (Figure
). An
investigator blinded to treatment assignment and outcome determined the
volume of the ischemic lesion. The unstained area of
ischemia on each slice was measured planimetrically by means of
a computerized image analyzer (Leica), and the volume of
ischemic brain, computed from these areas and the thickness of
the slices on the basis of a conic section model, was expressed in
mm3.
|
Hemodynamic and Laboratory Follow-up
Pulse rate and blood pressure were recorded
intra-arterially at baseline, at 1 minute after
embolization, and at 25 and 55 minutes after study drug initiation.
Blood samples were collected in citrated tubes (final concentration:
0.01 mol/L) at baseline and 55 minutes after drug initiation.
Laboratory measurements included fibrinogen,
2-antiplasmin, aPTT, and full blood cell count.
Bleeding Times
Bleeding times were simultaneously determined by
puncturing the depilated left ear (EBT) and by transecting the apex of
a nail cuticle (CBT), as previously described.21 Bleeding
times were recorded at baseline and at 25 minutes after drug
initiation. In rabbits receiving bolus infusions, additional bleeding
times were determined 5 minutes after the bolus.
Statistical Analysis
Data are expressed as mean±SEM, except for evolving infarct
size that is expressed as median and interquartile range. Student's
t test was used to compare paired parametric
variables. Repeated measures were analyzed using repeated
measures of variance and Friedman's nonparametric repeated
measures, for parametric and nonparametric
variables, respectively. To study correlations, the Spearman rank
correlation was used. One-way ANOVA was applied to compare the effects
of different agents (saline, Sak, and rTPA) and of different
administration schemes (lower-dose continuous infusion, higher-dose
continuous infusion, and bolus infusion) on the following dependent
variables (assessed posttreatment): percent lysis, clinical score,
infarct volume, plasma fibrinogen, plasma
2-antiplasmin,
aPTT, EBT, CBT, pulse, blood pressure, hemoglobin, final white blood
cell count, and final platelet count. All tests to determine
probability were two-sided; P<.05 was considered to
indicate statistical significance.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Percent clot lysis over 1 hour correlated significantly and inversely with evolving infarct size (r=-.58, P=.0001) and with clinical score (r=-.47, P=.0009) at 5 hours. A significant correlation was observed between evolving infarct size and clinical score (r=.67, P<.0001).
Table 2
shows pre- and posttreatment
values of fibrinogen,
2-antiplasmin, aPTT, and bleeding
times. A Sak dose of 1 mg/kg did not alter plasma fibrinogen or
2-antiplasmin levels, whereas after 2 mg/kg Sak
mean plasma fibrinogen dropped to almost 50% of baseline and
2-antiplasmin levels decreased modestly but
significantly. However, hemostatic derangements induced by rTPA were
significantly more pronounced: 3 mg/kg rTPA reduced mean
circulating levels of fibrinogen and
2-antiplasmin to
38% of baseline; 6 mg/kg rTPA, while further reducing
2-antiplasmin, produced virtually complete
fibrinogenolysis. Overall, rTPA reduced mean fibrinogen by 76%
compared with saline (P=.0001) and by 48% compared with Sak
(P=.0001). The effects on these hemostatic markers were
comparable, whether the higher doses of Sak or rTPA were given as an
infusion or as a bolus. Mean aPTT levels increased more than 2.5-fold
in rabbits treated with a thrombolytic agent plus
heparin. Compared with saline, mean aPTT was 56 seconds longer after
Sak and heparin (P=.03), and 83 seconds longer after rTPA
and heparin (P=.001).
|
EBTs or CBTs did not increase significantly after saline or Sak. However, bolus administration of rTPA, in contrast to infusions over 30 minutes, prolonged EBTs and CBTs substantially. EBT was significantly longer after rTPA than after Sak (P=.001), but CBT was not (P=.5).
The evolution of hemoglobin, white blood cell count, and platelets
is given in Table 3
. White blood cell
count decreased toward the end of the experiments, in control as well
as in actively treated animals, suggesting that leukopenia resulted
from the experimental procedure rather than from the infusions. Table 3
also shows the evolution of pulse rate and blood pressure. Study drugs
did not provoke hypotensive reactions.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sak versus rTPA in Rabbit Embolic Stroke
The extent of clot lysis with either rTPA or Sak in the
present model was relatively low (<50%) and was not enhanced by
doubling the dose. This absence of dose response was not unexpected for
rTPA. Indeed, in previous rabbit stroke experiments, an increase in
dose of rTPA of more than 3.3 mg/kg15 or 5
mg/kg23 over 30 minutes even resulted in decreased
thrombolysis. This effect was explained by the
"plasminogen-steal phenomenon"24 : high
doses of rTPA convert circulating plasminogen to plasmin,
resulting in a decrease of fibrin-associated plasminogen
and a reduction of the thrombolytic effect of rTPA.
This mechanism, however, cannot fully account for the unexpected lack
of dose response when doubling the dose of Sak, because the systemic
fibrinolytic effects of even 2 mg/kg Sak were relatively
moderate. An alternative explanation of the apparently low
thrombolytic plateau involves clot composition and
local, rather than systemic, plasmin concentrations. The partial
refractoriness to clot lysis may be due to compression of the thrombi
during preparation in catheters of decreasing diameter and during
injection into the intracranial arteries. Clot compression, as clot
retraction, may be associated with extrusion of plasminogen
and decreased clot lysability.25 26 During a run-in phase
before the present study, the embolization procedure was refined
and the size and number of clots were adapted, taking the extensive
intracranial collateral circulation of the rabbit into consideration.
This procedure yielded reproducible and quantifiable sublethal cerebral
infarcts in the majority of control animals.
Bolus administration of thrombolytic agents may improve the ease of administration. In the present model, however, the lytic efficacy of 6 mg/kg rTPA was decreased by 50% when it was infused over 1 minute instead of over 30 minutes, whereas bolus administration of 2 mg/kg Sak did not reduce its lytic potential. In patients with acute myocardial infarction, single boluses of rTPA have also produced lower coronary recanalization rates.27 Initial clinical experience suggests that (double) bolus administration of Sak produces efficient coronary thrombolysis.11 12
The lytic efficacies of infusions over 30 minutes of rTPA of 3 or 6 mg/kg and of Sak doses of 1 or 2 mg/kg were comparable, indicating that in the present model Sak and rTPA are about equipotent on a molar basis. However, the higher doses of rTPA produced profound hypofibrinogenemia, whereas Sak was more fibrin-specific. Intracranial hemorrhages were not observed, possibly due to the intact cerebral vasculature of these healthy rabbits and the short time (15 minutes) between embolization and start of drug infusion. Also, the interval of 5 hours between insult and macroscopic evaluation of the brain tissues may have been too short for the development of gross hemorrhagic conversion. It is increasingly recognized that intracranial hemorrhage complicating coronary thrombolysis in patients frequently originates from vessels with a pathological substrate such as cerebral amyloid vasculopathy28 or changes due to long-standing arterial hypertension.29 The risk of intracranial bleeding after cerebrovascular thrombolysis increases in accordance with the time between therapy and the onset of the ischemic symptoms,30 31 probably as a result of time-dependent loss of vascular integrity. The absence of cerebral bleeding in this model thus affirms that intact vessels protect against bleeding even in case of profound disruption of the circulating hemostatic system.32 33 Whether a systemic plasminolytic state promotes bleeding from damaged vessels is unclear from the present data.
The present study corroborates our previous finding that bolus administration of rTPA at doses that deplete circulating fibrinogen markedly prolongs bleeding times, especially when a short time elapses between bolus infusion and ear puncture or cuticle injury.21 Surprisingly, infusion over 30 minutes of the same dose of rTPA did not prolong bleeding times. The marked bleeding time prolongation by bolus rTPA may be caused by an initial excess of freely circulating rTPA that escapes complexation by plasminogen activator inhibitors. Although this mechanism remains unproven and the clinical significance of bleeding time prolongation and hypofibrinogenemia is still controversial, the present data call into question the efficacy and safety of high-dose intravenous bolus administration of rTPA. In line with this observation, a recent multicenter trial comparing a double bolus of rTPA with accelerated infusion in myocardial infarction patients was terminated early because of inferior benefit-to-risk ratio of double-bolus administration.34
Study Limitations
Although animal models constitute a valid tool to study the
mechanism of disease and pharmacological intervention,35
extrapolation to humans should only be made with caution. Rabbits were
chosen for practical and theoretical considerations. First, the rabbit
embolic stroke model is well established.15 23 36 37 38 39
Second, rabbits are easy to handle and the extracranial carotid
circulation can be identified and manipulated without the need for an
operation microscope. Third, the fibrin specificity of Sak and rTPA,
which is highly species-dependent, is comparable in rabbits and
humans.40
Hemostatic markers and bleeding times can at best only be regarded as surrogate markers for thrombolytic bleeding.32 Given the lack of sensitivity of our model for hemorrhagic conversion, the putative safety benefit of improved fibrin specificity could not be validated.
All study animals received aspirin and heparin in addition to either Sak or rTPA. This combined therapy reflects current practice in myocardial infarction management with (relatively) fibrin-specific thrombolytic agents. Conjunctive antithrombotic therapy optimizes coronary thrombolysis with these agents.41 However, the need for conjunctive therapy in cerebrovascular thrombolysis is not established. Recent data in a rabbit embolic stroke model even suggest that aspirin paradoxically attenuates rTPA-mediated lysis.42
In an effort to maximize efficacy, thrombolytic infusions were initiated 15 minutes after embolization of platelet-poor plasma clots into the rabbit's cerebral circulation. Prolonged time-to-treatment38 and increased platelet content of thrombi26 43 are likely to reduce the efficacy of thrombolytic agents.
Because 5 hours may be too early for a definite cerebral infarct to develop, it may be more prudent to consider the infarct zones as ischemic lesions in evolution. Histological assessment was not included in the present study. The 5-hour interval between injury and death was chosen because within this time window the majority of control animals developed severe neurological impairment, which rendered protracted observation undesirable.
Some of the anesthetic drugs used (eg, barbiturates and ketamine) have been claimed to have neuroprotective effects. Yet, they did not prevent control animals from developing significant ischemic lesions. However, a synergistic effect between these anesthetics and thrombolytic agents in reducing ischemia cannot be excluded.44
Conclusions
Very early intravenous administration of rTPA or Sak
in rabbits with an experimental embolic stroke reduced infarct size and
neurological deficit. In comparison with rTPA, Sak was more
fibrinogen-sparing and retained its thrombolytic
effects when administered as a bolus, without prolongation of bleeding
times. Further preclinical studies with Sak in cerebrovascular
thrombolysis appear to be warranted.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received December 17, 1996; revision received May 30, 1997; accepted June 3, 1997.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. Kirchhof, T. Welzel, S. Zoubaa, C. Lichy, M. Sikinger, H. L. de Ruiz, and K. Sartor New Method of Embolus Preparation for Standardized Embolic Stroke in Rabbits Stroke, September 1, 2002; 33(9): 2329 - 2333. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Nagai, M. De Mol, B. Van Hoef, M. Verstreken, and D. Collen Depletion of circulating {alpha}2-antiplasmin by intravenous plasmin or immunoneutralization reduces focal cerebral ischemic injury in the absence of arterial recanalization Blood, May 15, 2001; 97(10): 3086 - 3092. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Nagai, I. Vanlinthout, and D. Collen Comparative Effects of Tissue Plasminogen Activator, Streptokinase, and Staphylokinase on Cerebral Ischemic Infarction and Pulmonary Clot Lysis in Hamster Models Circulation, December 21, 1999; 100(25): 2541 - 2546. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Nagai, M. De Mol, H. R. Lijnen, P. Carmeliet, and D. Collen Role of Plasminogen System Components in Focal Cerebral Ischemic Infarction : A Gene Targeting and Gene Transfer Study in Mice Circulation, May 11, 1999; 99(18): 2440 - 2444. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Stroke Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1997 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |