(Stroke. 2000;31:2648.)
© 2000 American Heart Association, Inc.
Original Contributions |
From the St János Hospital (J.K.); St Imre Hospital (P.H.); Third Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Semmelweis University (Z.P., L.H., I.K., L.R., G.F.); Research Group of Metabolism, Genetic and Immunology, National Academy of Sciences (Z.P., L.H., I.K., A.C., L.R., G.F.); and First Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences, Semmelweis University (A.C.), Budapest, Hungary; and GBF and Technical University of Braunschweig, Braunschweig, Germany (M.S.). Drs Kramer and Harcos contributed equally to this work.
Correspondence to Dr George Füst, Third Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Semmelweis University, Budapest, Kútvölgyi út 4, H-1125, Hungary. E-mail FustGe{at}kut.sote.hu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MethodsWe studied 292 patients with CVD (stroke or transient ischemic attack) and as control either 198 healthy blood donors and 485 healthy elderly (aged >60 years) people (genetic study) or 94 blood donors aged 45 to 60 years and 49 healthy elderly (aged >60 years) people (antiheat-shock protein [hsp] measurements). Allele frequencies of 3 genes (C4A, C4B, and C3) encoding proteins of the complement system were determined by electrophoresis and immunofixation. Serum concentration of autoantibodies against 60-kDa heat-shock protein (anti-hsp60) was measured by the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay method.
ResultsMarked differences were observed between CVD patients and controls in the genetic studies. In the CVD patients aged >60 years, the frequency (11.3%) of the deficient allele of the C4B gene (C4B*Q0) was significantly (P=0.0003) higher than that of the healthy controls (5.4%). By contrast, in the group aged 45 to 60 years, the frequency of the C4B*Q0 allele was lower in patients than in controls. Serum concentration of anti-hsp60 in the CVD patients did not differ from control values.
ConclusionsIn previous studies C4B*Q0 frequency was reported to be higher in CHD patients aged 45 to 60 years than in aged-matched controls. Moreover, high anti-hsp60 levels were found in CHD patients. These findings contrast with our present report of lower frequency of C4B*Q0 in CVD patients. Therefore, genetic and immunologic factors may at least partly explain the differences between the natural history and risk factors of CHD and CVD.
Key Words: cerebrovascular disorders genetics heat-shock proteins stroke
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
When these observations are considered, strong similarities in the epidemiology of CHD and CVD may be expected. In contrast to this assumption, however, there is a marked quantitative, if not qualitative, difference in their important risk factors.8 Compared with myocardial infarction, stroke patients are at least 10 years older, the incidence in middle-aged men compared with women is not as great, and increasing blood pressure is more strongly associated with stroke, whereas increasing plasma cholesterol is less strongly associated with stroke.8 Part of the reason is presumably that so many epidemiological studies have considered all strokes together, thus weakening causal associations with ischemic stroke if they are not also associations with hemorrhagic stroke. However, this explanation is necessarily incomplete because most strokes are ischemic.8 According to the recent review article of Warlow,8 there is no doubt that new risk factors (including genetic factors) will emerge, some of which will have causal associations.
Previously we have found a highly significant association between the morbidity and mortality of myocardial infarction and C4B*Q0, the silent allele of 1 of the 2 genes encoding C4, a component of the complement system.9 The C4B*Q0 allele was found with increased frequency among myocardial infarction patients aged 60 to 79 years compared with age-matched healthy controls.9 Moreover, in C4B*Q0 carriers myocardial infarction had a significantly higher risk for lethal outcome compared with noncarriers.9 Recently we also found the frequency of the C4B*Q0 carriers to be significantly increased in Icelandic CHD patients.10 Therefore, we sought to determine whether the silent C4 allele is associated with CVD as well.
Much data have been accumulated in recent years that indicate the essential role of inflammation in atherogenesis11 and in the rupture of vulnerable plaques.12 Immunologic factors may have an important role in triggering and maintaining inflammation in arterial walls. According to the recent hypothesis of Wick et al,13 different stimuli leading to activation of endothelial cells may increase expression of heat-shock proteins (hsp) in these cells and induce cellular and humoral immune responses against these proteins or enhance preexisting immune responses. Many recent studies14 15 16 demonstrated antibodies in high titers against the 60-kDa family of hsp, such as human hsp60 or mycobacterial hsp65 in CHD patients. Since in CVD patients anti-hsp antibodies have not been measured thus far, in the present study we determined the amounts of the antibodies against human hsp60 and mycobacterial hsp65 in patients with CVD and in healthy control subjects.
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sera from 204 blood donors (aged 45 to 60 years; median, 53 years; 99 men, 105 women) as well as those from 485 healthy elderly (aged >60 years) people (195 men, 289 women)18 were used as controls for complement allotyping. The control group for anti-hsp measurements consisted of 94 blood donors aged 45 to 60 years and 49 healthy elderly (aged >60 years) people. Serum samples from the patients and controls were stored in aliquots at -70°C and thawed only once immediately before the tests were performed.
Study of Polymorphisms of the C4A, C4B, and C3 Genes
C4 typing was performed according to Awdeh and
Alper19 with the modification of Sim and
Cross.20 C3 allotypes were determined by the method of
Teisberg.21
Measurement of Antibodies Against Mycobacterial hsp65 and
Human hsp60
The amounts of IgG-type antibodies reacting with proteins of the
chaperonin 60 family (recombinant human hsp60, SPP-740, StressGen,
Victoria, Canada, and recombinant Mycobacterium bovis hsp65
[batch MA14, GBF, Germany; supported by the United Nations Development
Program/World Bank/World Health Organization Special Program for
Research and Training in Tropical Diseases]) were assessed by
enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay as described
previously.22 In brief, plates were coated
with 0.1 µg per well human hsp60 or M bovis hsp65.
After they were washed and blocked (PBS, 0.5% gelatin), wells were
incubated with 100 µL of serum samples diluted 1:500 in PBS
containing 0.5% gelatin and 0.05% Tween 20. Binding of anti-hsp
antibodies was determined with the use of
-chain specific anti-human
IgG peroxidase-labeled antibodies (Sigma) and
o-phenylenediamine (Sigma) detection system.
The optical density was measured at 490 nm (reference at 620 nm), and
means of duplicate wells were calculated. A serial dilution of a
control anti-hsp60 rabbit polyclonal antiserum (StressGen SPA-804, also
reacting with hsp65) was used as standard. Data obtained as optical
density values were calculated to arbitrary unit per milliliter (AU/mL)
values related to this standard.
Statistical Analysis
Categorical variables were compared with the Fishers exact
test. Since the variable antibody to hsp was not normally
distributed, nonparametric tests were used for group
comparisons. Spearman rank correlation coefficients were calculated for
estimation of interrelations between hsp antibodies and other
variables. The significance level was set at a value of
P<0.05. The relationship between the levels of anti-hsp
antibodies and the extent of ultrasonographic alterations in carotid
arteries was calculated by logistic regression analysis.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 test for trend), a significant relationship
(P=0.040) between age and C4B*Q0 allele was found. Since
previously we found pronounced age-dependent changes in the frequency
of the silent allele of C4B, the patients were divided into 2 age
groups (45 to 60 years and >60 years) and compared with age-matched
controls. For the younger age group of patients, healthy subjects from
the present study were used as controls, while the results obtained
in the second age group of CVD patients were compared with those of 485
healthy elderly (aged >60 years) people from our previous
study.18 For both age groups of patients, similar
frequencies were found for all complement alleles in series 1 and
2. For example, in the younger group the frequencies of C4B*Q0 were
0.0643 and 0.0645 (P=0.999), respectively, while in the
older group in series 1 and 2, frequencies of 0.128 and 0.101
(P=0.416), respectively, were found.
Frequencies of the complement alleles were compared in 191 CVD
patients aged >60 years and in 485 age-matched controls (Table
). The frequency of the C4B*Q0 allele
was significantly higher in the elderly patients than in the
age-matched healthy elderly people. Significant differences between the
patients and controls aged >60 years were also found in 2 relatively
rare alleles of the C4A gene. In CVD patients the frequency of the
C4A*2 allele was relatively low, while that of the C4A*4 allele
was relatively high.
|
In sharp contrast to the findings in the older age group, the allele frequency of C4B*Q0 in 101 CVD patients aged 45 to 60 years was significantly (P=0.044) lower, almost one half of the frequency observed in 204 age-matched control subjects. This decrease was compensated with a significantly higher occurrence of the C4B*1 allele in these patients. The frequency of the C4B*Q0 allele was lower in the male (0.059) than in the female (0.085) patients, but the difference was not statistically significant. No significant differences between CVD patients and controls were found in the frequencies of any other alleles tested (data not shown).
Significant differences (P=0.001) were found between
patients aged
60 and >60 years in the proportion of those with TIA
and ischemic stroke as well: TIA was observed in 37% and 14%
of the patients, respectively. CHD was found in 35% and 43% of the
patients, respectively; the difference between the 2 groups, however,
was not significant. We performed a logistic regression
analysis and found significant differences between the 2 age
groups in the frequency of C4B*Q0 carriers even after adjustment for
the TIA/stroke proportion, occurrence of CHD, and age.
When the series 2 patients with hemorrhagic stroke and TIA were
excluded from the evaluation, ie, the analysis was restricted
to the patients with ischemic stroke, the frequencies of the
different alleles were very similar to those obtained in the whole
group of CVD patients. For example, in the 99 patients aged >60 years
with ischemic stroke, the C4B*Q0 frequency was 21 of 198
(0.106), very close (P=0.889) to the frequency of 0.113 in
the Table
.
The limited number of patients tested did not allow a precise analysis of the possible connection between clinical subgroups of the patients and the complement allotypes.
Measurement of Antibodies Against hsp in CVD Patients and
Healthy Controls
Serum concentrations of the antibodies against human hsp60
(Figure
, panel A) and mycobacterial hsp65
(Figure
, panel B) were determined in healthy controls and in
series 2 of CVD patients. No significant differences were found between
patients and controls in the case of either anti-hsp60 antibodies
(P=0.21) or anti-hsp65 antibodies (P=0.71).
|
We found a significant positive correlation between age and anti-hsp65 antibodies in both controls (R=0.26, P<0.0001) and CVD patients (R=0.13, P=0.03). Anti-hsp60 antibodies correlated with age only in the control group (R=0.15, P=0.01).
No differences in serum concentrations of anti-hsp60 and anti-hsp65 antibodies were observed in the comparison of patients with hemorrhagic and ischemic stroke (data not shown). Levels of anti-hsp60 and hsp65 antibodies were about the same in 20 patients with TIA and 98 with ischemic stroke: 56.9 (25th to 75th percentile, 20.6 to 91.1) and 56.2 (25th to 75th percentile, 36.7 to 89.8) AU/mL, respectively, for anti-hsp60 antibodies, and 6.08 (25th to 75th percentile, 2.95 to 9.35) and 8.86 (25th to 75th percentile, 4.80 to 15.72) AU/mL, respectively, for anti-hsp65 antibodies. As calculated by nonparametric ANOVA (Kruskal-Wallis test), there were also no differences in serum concentrations of anti-hsp60 or anti-hsp65 antibodies between different subgroups17 of ischemic stroke (data not shown).
The serum concentration of anti-hsp65 antibodies (but not of anti-hsp60 antibodies) was found to be higher in CVD patients with major ultrasonographic alterations (median, 9.2 AU/mL; 25th to 75th percentile, 4.7 to 16.4 AU/mL) than in those with no or only minor alterations (median, 5.7 AU/mL; 25th to 75th percentile, 3.7 to 8.9 AU/mL). The difference was of borderline significance (P=0.049). However, when the data were analyzed by the multiple regression method, it was determined that the difference was only an apparent one because the average age of the former group was significantly (P=0.0007) higher than that of the latter group.
Lack of Relationship Between C4B*Q0 Allele and Serum
Concentration of Anti-hsp Antibodies
In the carriers and noncarriers of the C4B*Q0 allele, the
levels of antibodies against hsp did not significantly differ. Median
and interquartile range values of the anti-hsp60 antibodies were 78.8
(34.4 to 103.9) and 51.5 (30.5 to 82.2) AU/mL, respectively
(P=0.151). In the case of anti-hsp65 antibodies, values were
7.2 (5.1 to 12.3) and 8.6 (4.5 to 15.7) AU/mL (P=0.934).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The leading cause of death in Hungary, as in many other parts of the developed world, is CHD and its consequence, myocardial infarction. In populations of Hungary and Iceland, we have obtained much evidence indicating that the morbidity in CHD and myocardial infarction is significantly higher in C4B*Q0 carriers than in noncarriers.9 10 The difference in frequency between these patients and age-matched healthy controls was highest in elderly subjects aged >60 years. In the present study we found the frequency of the C4B*Q0 allele in CVD patients aged >60 years to be 0.113, which is more than twice that obtained in our previous study9 in healthy subjects of the same age (0.054). Therefore, the frequency of C4B*Q0 in CVD patients aged >60 years is comparable to that in CHD patients aged >60 years23 and in patients with myocardial infarction aged 60 to 79 years.9 Furthermore, C4B*Q0 frequency was highest in CVD patients aged >70 years. Therefore, our present findings indicate that carriers of the C4B*Q0 allele are more susceptible not only to CHD but to CVD, but in the case of CVD the disease is manifested primarily in the elderly.
In sharp contrast to the elderly patients, in CVD patients aged 45 to 60 years the frequency of the C4B*Q0 allele (0.064) was lower than in age-matched healthy individuals. If this observation can be repeated in a larger cohort of young CVD patients, it indicates a different genetic background for the 2 disease entities of atherosclerotic vascular diseases when they develop in middle-aged subjects. This finding is in agreement with some data in the literature.24 25
In the second part of the present study we compared the serum concentration of the antibodies against human hsp60 or mycobacterial hsp65 in patients and controls. These antibodies were shown to be a marker of cardiovascular disease and carotid atherosclerosis by several groups.14 15 16 26 27 No similar studies in CVD patients have been reported, however.
Our present findings indicate that there is no difference in the average serum levels of either anti-hsp60 or anti-hsp65 antibodies between CVD patients and age-matched healthy subjects. The only clinical association we found was a correlation between the severity of ultrasonographic alterations in carotid arteries and anti-hsp65 titers. When the difference was analyzed by a multiple regression test, however, we found that the difference was due to the higher average age of the patients with severe carotid alterations compared with those with mild ones. Previously, Xu et al27 28 also found an age-dependent increase of anti-hsp65 antibody levels in healthy inhabitants of the southern Tirol region with carotid atherosclerosis compared with those with no alterations. Since the prevalence of carotid alterations increased with age, similar to our present findings, they also found an increase in the anti-hsp65 antibody titers. The lack of elevated serum concentrations of anti-hsp60 and hsp65 antibodies in CVD patients is in sharp contrast to findings obtained in CHD, in which the levels of anti-hsp antibodies were found to be high.14 15 The overexpression of hsp in endothelial cells is an initiating event of local immune complex formation and complement activation22 that may significantly contribute to the development of atherosclerosis.29 30 When one considers the parallel development of atherosclerosis in coronary and carotid arteries, our present findings on the lack of elevated anti-hsp antibodies in CVD patients indicate that the same stimuli that increase hsp expression in coronary arteries do not induce it in the endothelial cells of carotid arteries. Experiments addressing this hypothesis are in progress in our laboratories.
Thus, our present findings indicate marked differences between CHD and CVD in one of the immune mechanisms that may contribute to atherogenesis. We have found an even more pronounced difference in another immune mechanism, namely, the formation of anticholesterol antibodies.31 Compared with age-matched healthy subjects, serum concentration of anticholesterol antibodies was significantly lower in CVD patients but significantly higher in CHD patients.31
When these differences in immune mechanisms as well as the difference between CHD and CVD patients in the frequency of the C4B*Q0 complement allele are taken into account, it seems that there are marked differences in genetic background and immunopathological factors that contribute of the pathomechanism of CHD and ischemic stroke. The nonidentity of these factors may at least partly explain the differences between the natural history and risk factors of CHD and CVD.8
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received January 11, 2000; revision received July 28, 2000; accepted July 28, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
B. Blasko, R. Kolka, P. Thorbjornsdottir, S. T. Sigurtharson, G. Sigurthsson, Z. Ronai, M. Sasvari-Szekely, S. Bothvarsson, G. Thorgeirsson, Z. Prohaszka, et al. Low complement C4B gene copy number predicts short-term mortality after acute myocardial infarction Int. Immunol., January 1, 2008; 20(1): 31 - 37. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Veres, G. Fust, M. Smieja, M. McQueen, A. Horvath, Q. Yi, A. Biro, J. Pogue, L. Romics, I. Karadi, et al. Relationship of Anti-60 kDa Heat Shock Protein and Anti-Cholesterol Antibodies to Cardiovascular Events Circulation, November 26, 2002; 106(22): 2775 - 2780. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Stroke Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2000 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |