(Stroke. 2001;32:1825.)
© 2001 American Heart Association, Inc.
Original Contributions |
From the Departments of Radiology (I.Y., T.N., H.S.) and Neurosurgery (Y.M.), Faculty of Medicine, Tokyo Medical and Dental University, Tokyo, Japan.
Correspondence to Ichiro Yamada, MD, Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine, Tokyo Medical and Dental University, 1-5-45 Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-8519, Japan. E-mail yamada.crad{at}med.tmd.ac.jp
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods Forty-six patients suspected of having moyamoya disease were examined with high-resolution turbo MR angiography with the ZFI technique, MRI, and conventional angiography. Moyamoya disease was diagnosed in 42 of these patients. Blind, separate interpretation of the images was performed.
Results High-resolution turbo MR angiography and MRI accurately evaluated 349 (95%) and 325 (88%) of 368 arteries, respectively, but the degree of stenosis was overestimated in the other arteries. MR angiography and MRI depicted basal cerebral moyamoya vessels in 82 (98%) and 82 (98%) of 84 hemispheres, respectively. MR angiography also depicted leptomeningeal and transdural collateral vessels in 51 (100%) of 51 hemispheres and in 38 (88%) of 43 hemispheres, respectively. The sensitivity and specificity of high-resolution turbo MR angiography for the diagnosis of moyamoya disease were 98% and 100%, respectively.
Conclusions High-resolution turbo MR angiography in reduced scan time is highly accurate in the assessment of both steno-occlusive lesions and collateral vessels in moyamoya disease, thus providing a highly accurate (98%) diagnosis and assessment of moyamoya disease.
Key Words: angiography angiography, magnetic resonance magnetic resonance imaging moyamoya disease
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Recently, turbo MR angiography with zero-filling interpolation (ZFI) technique has been proposed as a new technique to reduce scan time for the evaluation of cerebrovascular diseases.7,8 The ZFI along the slice direction generates thinner slice sections, and the ZFI along the in-plane phase-encoding direction increases the matrix size of the direction.710 Thus, the ZFI technique allows for high-resolution turbo MR angiography in less scan time. To our knowledge, however, no study has described the application of high-resolution turbo MR angiography with the ZFI technique to patients with moyamoya disease, and no attempt has been made to compare the sensitivity and specificity of high-resolution turbo MR angiography with those of conventional angiography. We present the results of a prospective study that was undertaken to determine the clinical efficacy of high-resolution turbo MR angiography, compared with that of conventional angiography, in the diagnosis of moyamoya disease.
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
On the basis of findings at conventional angiography in the remaining 4 patients, 2 patients had unilateral steno-occlusive lesions consisting of either stenosis or occlusion of the MCA, but moyamoya disease was not diagnosed because the lesions were unilateral without MMVs. Findings in the other 2 patients were within the normal range, and ultimately no overt organic diseases were found.
In this prospective study, we enrolled the 46 consecutive patients who were clinically suspected of having moyamoya disease, and the group turned out to include 42 patients with moyamoya disease and 4 patients without moyamoya disease. Thus, we used this patient group to determine the sensitivity and specificity of the technique. The study protocol was approved by the institutional review board, and informed consent was obtained from all patients.
Imaging Examinations
A 1.5-T superconducting system with a 25-mT/m maximum gradient capability (Magnetom Vision; Siemens) and a circularly polarized head coil was used to obtain all MR images. High-resolution turbo MR angiography was performed with a 3-dimensional fast imaging with steady-state precession (FISP) sequence with the parameters of 35.0/6.4 milliseconds (repetition time/echo time), flip angle of 20 degrees, and 1 signal acquired. Magnetization transfer contrast (MTC), tilted optimized nonsaturated excitation (TONE), and multislab techniques were also used. The field of view was 175x200 mm (7/8 rectangular field of view) with a matrix of 224 (160)x512, resulting in the in-plane resolution of 0.78x0.39 mm. Using the ZFI technique, the effective phase-encoding matrix was increased from 160 to 224. Using the asymmetric ZFI technique, the standard section thickness was reduced from 1.33 to 0.7 mm. The other imaging parameters included 3 slabs, thickness of all slabs of 72 mm, thickness of 1 slab of 32 mm, 24 partitions in 1 slab, and an overlapping rate of 38%, which gave 108 sections with a section thickness of 0.7 mm after ZFI. The total acquisition time of turbo MR angiography was 6 minutes 44 seconds. The multislab imaging volume was oriented axially to cover the circle of Willis and included the distribution of the MCA and posterior cerebral artery (PCA). After data acquisition was completed and each of the 108 sections was reconstructed, MR angiograms in different view directions were obtained by means of a maximum intensity projection (MIP) algorithm. To interpret MR angiograms, both the MIP and section images were reviewed.
In all patients, axial T1-weighted spin-echo images (600/14) were obtained with 2 signals averaged. The T1-weighted images were acquired with a field of view of 165x220 mm, a matrix of 192x256, and a section thickness of 5 mm with a 1-mm intersection gap. Axial T2-weighted turbo spin-echo images (4000/96, echo train length 7) were obtained with 2 signals averaged. The T2-weighted images were acquired with a field of view of 165x220 mm, a matrix of 210x512, and a section thickness of 5 mm with a 1-mm intersection gap.
All patients also underwent conventional angiography that included bilateral internal and external carotid arteriography and unilateral or bilateral vertebral arteriography, with the use of the transfemoral catheterization technique. Conventional angiography was performed within 1 month before or after MR angiography and MRI.
Image Analysis
MR accuracy was studied by means of blinded, separate interpretations of MR angiograms, MR images, and conventional angiograms made by 2 independent observers (I.Y., T.N.). The conventional angiograms were used as the gold standard in analysis of the MR findings, and the MR angiograms and MR images were independently interpreted, without knowledge of the angiographic findings. In interpretation of the MR images, we used both T1- and T2-weighted images for image analysis. The observers were unaware of the frequency of disease in the patient group. When the observers did not fully agree on the findings, the diagnosis was achieved through discussion.
In a lesion-by-lesion analysis, MR angiographic and MRI findings were reviewed for signs of steno-occlusive lesions and for the presence of basal cerebral MMVs, leptomeningeal collateral vessels, and transdural collateral vessels. These MR findings were also compared on a lesion-by-lesion basis with the findings of conventional angiography. The standard scoring scheme used for steno-occlusive lesions has 3 grades: normal, stenotic, and occluded. "Stenotic" indicated a focal narrowing of the lumen, whereas "occluded" indicated the absence or discontinuity of the lumen. Four arteries were scored bilaterally: the supraclinoid ICA, the proximal ACA, the proximal MCA, and the proximal PCA. Furthermore, based on their presence and appearance, abnormal basal cerebral MMVs were graded as none, mild, or marked. "Mild" indicated that the MMVs were a small vascular network localized in the basal ganglia and the medullary arteries were not depicted, whereas "marked" indicated that the MMVs were a large vascular network that extended above the basal ganglia and the medullary arteries were depicted. These criteria for steno-occlusive lesions and MMVs were commonly used to describe findings at MR angiography, MRI, and conventional angiography.
In a patient-by-patient analysis, conventional angiographic criteria were used to determine the diagnosis of moyamoya disease: (1) the presence of bilateral stenosis or occlusion involving the supraclinoid portion of the ICA and the proximal portions of the ACA and MCA and (2) the presence of bilateral abnormal basal cerebral MMVs. MR angiographic and MRI criteria for moyamoya disease were the same as for those of conventional angiography: (1) depiction of bilateral narrowing or absence of lumen in the supraclinoid ICA and in the proximal ACA and MCA and (2) depiction of bilateral abnormal basal cerebral MMVs.
Finally, statistical analysis was performed with the
2 test or the Fisher exact test between groups. P<0.05 was considered statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
|
Steno-Occlusive Lesions
Of a total of 368 arteries that were studied, high-resolution turbo MR angiography and MRI accurately evaluated 349 (95%) and 325 (88%) arteries, respectively (Table 1 and Figure 1). All 165 occlusions were correctly identified with MR angiography and MRI. However, on the basis of findings at MR angiography and MRI, respectively, the degree of stenosis was overestimated as occluded in 18 and 32 of 107 stenotic arteries and as stenotic in 1 and 11 of 96 normal arteries (Figure 2).
|
|
The sensitivity and specificity, respectively, for the detection of steno-occlusive lesions were 100% and 99% for high-resolution turbo MR angiography and 100% and 89% for MRI (Table 4). The specificity of high-resolution turbo MR angiography was significantly higher than that of MRI (P<0.01). In determining the sensitivity and specificity for the detection of steno-occlusive lesions, we combined the results for stenosis and occlusion, because this was necessary to determine the efficacy for the detection of stenotic and occlusive disease.
Of the 92 supraclinoid ICAs evaluated with MR angiography and MRI, respectively, 87 (95%) and 83 (90%) were correctly evaluated, and 5 and 9 stenotic ICAs were diagnosed as occluded. Of the 92 ACAs evaluated with MR angiography and MRI, respectively, 86 (93%) and 78 (85%) were correctly evaluated, and 6 and 14 stenotic ACAs were diagnosed as occluded. Of the 92 MCAs evaluated with MR angiography and MRI, respectively, 84 (91%) and 83 (90%) were correctly evaluated, 7 and 8 stenotic MCAs were diagnosed as occluded, and 1 normal MCA was diagnosed as stenotic with each modality. Of the 92 PCAs evaluated with MR angiography and MRI, respectively, 92 (100%) and 81 (88%) were correctly evaluated, 1 stenotic PCA was diagnosed as occluded only with MRI, and 10 normal PCAs were diagnosed as stenotic only with MRI.
Basal Cerebral MMVs
Of a total of 92 cerebral hemispheres that were studied, high-resolution turbo MR angiography and MRI accurately graded basal cerebral MMVs in 90 (98%) and 90 (98%) hemispheres, respectively (Table 2 and Figure 1). In 84 cerebral hemispheres in which moyamoya disease was manifest, MMVs were not detected in only 2 hemispheres (2%) with high-resolution turbo MR angiography. Similarly, MMVs were not detected in only 2 hemispheres (2%) with MRI.
Therefore, the sensitivity and specificity, respectively, for the detection of MMVs were 98% and 100% for high-resolution turbo MR angiography and 98% and 100% for MRI (Table 4). The accuracy of high-resolution turbo MR angiography was comparable to that of MRI (P>0.05).
Leptomeningeal and Transdural Collateral Vessels
On the basis of findings at conventional angiography, leptomeningeal collateral vessels from the posterior to the anterior circulation were present in 51 cerebral hemispheres (Table 3). High-resolution turbo MR angiography depicted leptomeningeal collateral vessels in all 51 cerebral hemispheres (100%) (Figure 1). MRI depicted leptomeningeal collateral vessels in 38 cerebral hemispheres (75%) but failed to identify leptomeningeal collateral vessels in 13 other hemispheres. Thus, the respective sensitivity and specificity for the detection of leptomeningeal collateral vessels were 100% and 100% for high-resolution turbo MR angiography and 75% and 100% for MRI. The sensitivity of high-resolution turbo MR angiography was significantly higher than that of MRI (Table 4) (P<0.001).
On the basis of findings at conventional angiography, transdural collateral vessels were present in 43 cerebral hemispheres (Table 3). High-resolution turbo MR angiography depicted transdural collateral vessels in 38 hemispheres (88%) (Figure 3), although it failed to identify transdural collateral vessels in 5 hemispheres. However, MRI detected no transdural collateral vessels in the 43 cerebral hemispheres. Thus, the respective sensitivity and specificity for the detection of transdural collateral vessels were 88% and 100% for high-resolution turbo MR angiography and 0% and 100% for MRI. The sensitivity of high-resolution turbo MR angiography was significantly higher than that of MRI (P<0.001) (Table 4).
|
Patient-by-Patient Analysis
Bilateral steno-occlusive lesions were depicted with both high-resolution turbo MR angiography and MRI in all 42 patients with moyamoya disease and were not detected in 4 patients without moyamoya disease. Thus, the respective sensitivity and specificity for the detection of bilateral steno-occlusive lesions were 100% for high-resolution turbo MR angiography and 100% for MRI (P>0.05) (Table 5).
Among 42 patients with moyamoya disease, bilateral basal cerebral MMVs were detected in 41 patients with both high-resolution turbo MR angiography and MRI, but a false-negative result was obtained in 1 patient with both MR angiography and MRI. Thus, the respective sensitivity and specificity for the detection of bilateral basal cerebral MMVs were 98% and 100% for high-resolution turbo MR angiography and MRI (P>0.05) (Table 5).
Therefore, on the basis of the diagnostic criteria of bilateral steno-occlusive lesions and bilateral basal cerebral MMVs, the respective sensitivity and specificity for diagnosis of moyamoya disease were 98% and 100% for high-resolution turbo MR angiography and MRI (P>0.05) (Table 5).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The results of a lesion-by-lesion analysis showed that high-resolution turbo MR angiography had a sensitivity of 100%, a specificity of 99%, and an accuracy of 100% for the detection of steno-occlusive lesions. Furthermore, in 349 (95%) of the 368 arteries that were studied, the grade of steno-occlusive lesions determined by high-resolution turbo MR angiography was consistent with that determined by conventional angiography. It must be noted that severely stenotic arteries may be overestimated as occluded with MR angiography. However, given an accuracy of 100%, high-resolution turbo MR angiography seems to be an alternative method to detect steno-occlusive lesions in patients with moyamoya disease.
In the lesion-by-lesion evaluation, high-resolution turbo MR angiography was found to have a sensitivity of 98%, a specificity of 100%, and an accuracy of 98% for the detection of basal cerebral MMVs. Furthermore, in 90 (98%) of the 92 cerebral hemispheres, the grade of MMVs determined with MR angiography was consistent with that determined with conventional angiography. This accuracy was comparable with that of MRI. It must be noted that very mild MMVs may be underestimated with MR angiography. However, given an accuracy of 98%, high-resolution turbo MR angiography seems to be an alternative method for the detection of basal cerebral MMVs in patients with moyamoya disease.
The results of a patient-by-patient analysis also substantiated the validity of high-resolution turbo MR angiography in the diagnosis of moyamoya disease. High-resolution turbo MR angiography for bilateral steno-occlusive lesions of the internal carotid bifurcation had a 100% sensitivity and 100% specificity. High-resolution turbo MR angiography for bilateral basal cerebral MMVs had 98% sensitivity and 100% specificity. Thus, high-resolution turbo MR angiography for the diagnosis of moyamoya disease was found to be 98% sensitive and 100% specific. Given an accuracy of 98%, high-resolution turbo MR angiography appears to be a valid alternative method with which to achieve a diagnosis of moyamoya disease. We compared the sensitivity and specificity of high-resolution turbo MR angiography with those of conventional angiography for the diagnosis of moyamoya disease. We did not perform conventional MR angiography, due to limited examination times, and we compared high-resolution turbo MR angiography, MRI, and conventional angiography. The accuracy (98%) of high-resolution turbo MR angiography in the present study was higher than that (79%) of conventional MR angiography in the previous reports.14,15
Turbo MR angiography measures less data than conventional MR angiography, and the residual spaces in the k-space are filled with zeros, thus reducing the scan time.7,8 The ZFI technique generates thinner slice sections and increases matrix size along the in-plane phase-encoding direction. Thus, the ZFI technique allows for high-resolution turbo MR angiography in less scan time. A prominent limitation of conventional MR angiography is that the spatial resolution is much lower than that of conventional angiography.11,14,15 However, by using high-resolution turbo MR angiography with the ZFI technique, thinner slice sections with increased matrix size can be obtained in reduced scan time.710 This probably accounts for why high-resolution turbo MR angiography in reduced scan time had a high degree of accuracy for the evaluation of both steno-occlusive lesions and basal cerebral MMVs compared with that of conventional MR angiography in previous reports.1116 Furthermore, we used other new imaging techniques, including MTC, TONE, and multislab, in the pulse sequence of high-resolution turbo MR angiography.1720 These techniques also appear to contribute to a higher accuracy of high-resolution turbo MR angiography in reduced scan time than that of conventional MR angiography in earlier reports that did not use these techniques.1116
The present results also demonstrated that high-resolution turbo MR angiography had a high level of accuracy (100%) for the detection of leptomeningeal collateral vessels from the PCA to the anterior circulation. Recent reports have shown that the presence of leptomeningeal collateral vessels is significantly correlated with regional cerebral blood flow and perfusion in moyamoya disease.21,22 Thus, high-resolution turbo MR angiography appears to be highly reliable for the assessment of cerebral ischemia in moyamoya disease. Furthermore, results of the present study have shown a high level of accuracy (95%) for the detection of transdural collateral vessels by high-resolution turbo MR angiography. Recently, surgical revascularization has been 1 treatment option for moyamoya disease, so postoperative vascular imaging has been needed to evaluate bypass patency.23 In this regard, our data demonstrate that high-resolution turbo MR angiography in reduced scan time is also suitable for the postoperative evaluation of bypass surgery in patients with moyamoya disease.
Another important aspect of moyamoya disease is its hereditary tendency, showing occasional familial occurrence.11,12 Therefore, high-resolution turbo MR angiography might have a role in the screening of asymptomatic relatives of patients with moyamoya disease. The regional cerebral blood flow in moyamoya disease is decreased in areas with severe steno-occlusive lesions and no collateral vessels.21,22 Thus, high-resolution turbo MR angiography, which accurately evaluates steno-occlusive lesions and collateral vessels, appears to be highly reliable for the detection of low flow. Recently, contrast-enhanced MR angiography has been reported for intracranial arterial disease.24 Compared with the time-of-flight technique, contrast-enhanced MR angiography may have some gain in efficacy because the arterial signal is less dependent on flow effects.
In conclusion, high-resolution turbo MR angiography in reduced scan time was found to have a high degree of accuracy (98% to 100%) for the assessment of both the steno-occlusive lesions and collateral vessels in patients with moyamoya disease. Furthermore, it also depicted leptomeningeal and transdural collateral vessels with a high degree of accuracy (95% to 100%). Therefore, high-resolution turbo MR angiography in reduced scan time is a valid alternative method to provide a highly accurate (98%), definitive diagnosis and assessment of moyamoya disease.
Received October 9, 2000; revision received January 8, 2001; accepted April 26, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2.
Suzuki J, Takaku A. Cerebrovascular "moyamoya" disease: disease showing abnormal net-like vessels in base of brain. Arch Neurol. 1969; 20: 288299.
3. Taveras JM. Multiple progressive intracranial arterial occlusions: a syndrome of children and young adults. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1969; 106: 235268.
4. Pecker J, Simon J, Guy G, Herry JF. Nishimotos disease: significance of its angiographic appearances. Neuroradiology. 1973; 5: 223230.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
5.
Takahashi M. Magnification angiography in moyamoya disease: new observations on collateral vessels. Radiology. 1980; 136: 379386.
6. Yamada I, Himeno Y, Suzuki S, Matsushima Y. Posterior circulation in moyamoya disease: angiographic study. Radiology. 1995; 107: 239246.
7. Shigematsu Y, Korogi Y, Hirai T, Okuda T, Sugahara T, Liang L, Takahashi M. 3D TOF turbo MR angiography for intracranial arteries: phantom and clinical studies. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1999; 10: 939944.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
8. Kominami M, Yamada N, Imakita S, Uchida R, Kuribayashi S, Kimura K, Takamiya M. MR angiography of steno-occlusive lesions of intracranial arteries: a comparative study between turbo MRA and conventional MRA. Nippon Igaku Hoshasen Gakkai Zasshi. 1999; 59: 504509.In Japanese.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
9.
Hylton NM, Simovsky I, Li AJ, Hale JD. Impact of section doubling on MR angiography. Radiology. 1992; 185: 899902.
10. Du YP, Parker DL, Davis WL, Cao G. Reduction of partial-volume artifacts with zero-filling interpolation in three-dimensional MR angiography. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1994; 4: 733741.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
11.
Yamada I, Matsushima Y, Suzuki S. Moyamoya disease: diagnosis with three-dimensional time-of-flight MR angiography. Radiology. 1992; 184: 773778.
12. Houkin K, Aoki T, Takahashi A, Abe H. Diagnosis of moyamoya disease with magnetic resonance angiography. Stroke. 1994; 25: 21592164.[Abstract]
13. Makiyama Y, Nishimoto H, Aihara T, Tsubokawa T. Magnetic resonance angiography in the management of childhood moyamoya disease: first choice for neurovascular scrutiny. Surg Neurol. 1994; 42: 3240.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
14.
Yamada I, Suzuki S, Matsushima Y. Moyamoya disease: comparison of assessment with MR angiography and MR imaging versus conventional angiography. Radiology. 1995; 196: 211218.
15. Hasuo K, Mihara F, Matsushima T. MRI and MR angiography in moyamoya disease. J Magn Reson Imaging. 1998; 8: 762766.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
16. Saeki N, Silva MN, Kubota M, Takanashi J, Sugita K, Nakazaki S, Yamaura A. Comparative performance of magnetic resonance angiography and conventional angiography in moyamoya disease. J Clin Neurosci. 2000; 7: 112115.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
17.
Edelman RR, Ahn SS, Chien D, Li W, Goldmann A, Mantello M, Kramer J, Kleefield J. Improved time-of-flight MR angiography of the brain with magnetization transfer contrast. Radiology. 1992; 184: 395399.
18.
Atkinson D, Brant-Zawadzki M, Gillan G, Purdy D, Laub G. Improved MR angiography: magnetization transfer suppression with variable flip angle excitation and increased resolution. Radiology. 1994; 190: 890894.
19.
Blatter DD, Parker DL, Ahn SS, Bahr AL, Robinson RO, Schwartz RB, Jolesz FA, Boyer RS. Cerebral MR angiography with multiple overlapping thin slab acquisition, part II: early clinical experience. Radiology. 1992; 183: 379389.
20.
Davis WL, Blatter DD, Harnsberger HR, Parker DL. Intracranial MR angiography: comparison of single-volume three-dimensional time-of-flight and multiple overlapping thin slab acquisition techniques. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1994; 163: 915920.
21.
Yamada I, Murata Y, Umehara I, Suzuki S, Matsushima Y. SPECT and MRI evaluations of the posterior circulation in moyamoya disease. J Nucl Med. 1996; 37: 16131617.
22.
Yamada I, Himeno Y, Nagaoka T, Akimoto H, Matsushima Y, Kuroiwa T, Shibuya H. Moyamoya disease: evaluation with diffusion-weighted and perfusion echo-planar MR imaging. Radiology. 1999; 212: 340347.
23. Yamada I, Matsushima Y, Suzuki S. Childhood moyamoya disease before and after encephalo-duro-arterio-synangiosis: an angiographic study. Neuroradiology. 1992; 34: 318322.[Medline] [Order article via Infotrieve]
24.
Metens T, Rio F, Baleriaux D, Roger T, David P, Rodesch G. Intracranial aneurysms: detection with gadolinium-enhanced dynamic three-dimensional MR angiography-initial results. Radiology. 2000; 216: 3946.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. Kuriyama, Y. Kusaka, M. Fujimura, K. Wakai, A. Tamakoshi, S. Hashimoto, I. Tsuji, Y. Inaba, and T. Yoshimoto Prevalence and Clinicoepidemiological Features of Moyamoya Disease in Japan: Findings From a Nationwide Epidemiological Survey Stroke, January 1, 2008; 39(1): 42 - 47. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. W. Neff, P. Horn, P. Schmiedek, C. Duber, and D. J. Dinter 2D cine phase-contrast MRI for volume flow evaluation of the brain-supplying circulation in moyamoya disease. Am. J. Roentgenol., July 1, 2006; 187(1): W107 - W115. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Stroke Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2001 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |