| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
(Stroke. 2003;34:2410.)
© 2003 American Heart Association, Inc.
Original Contributions |
From the Department of Neurosurgery, Kumamoto University School of Medicine, Kumamoto, Japan.
Reprint requests to Tatemi Todaka, MD, Department of Neurosurgery, Kumamoto University School of Medicine, 1-1-1 Honjo, Kumamoto 860-8556, Japan. E-mail ossan{at}fc.kuh.kumamoto-u.ac.jp
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods Morphological features such as the number and diameter of draining and feeding vessels and the AVM nidus volume were evaluated in 30 patients with supratentorial AVMs. The MTT of feeding arteries and draining veins was measured with the use of time-density curves obtained by digital subtraction angiography. The correlation between hemorrhage and morphology and hemorrhage and MTT was analyzed statistically.
Results The nidus volume was not significantly different between hemorrhagic and nonhemorrhagic AVMs. However, between ruptured and unruptured AVMs there was a significant difference in the mean number of draining veins (1.5±0.69 versus 2.3±0.50; P=0.006), the MTT of the feeding artery (1.10±0.24 versus 1.62±0.55; P=0.03), and the ratio of the MTT of the draining to the feeding vessels (1.71±0.43 versus 1.05±0.07; P<0.001).
Conclusions A high ratio of the MTT of draining veins to feeding arteries suggests disequilibrium between nidal inflow and outflow. The consequent increased pressure in the draining vein may contribute to the development of AVM hemorrhage.
Key Words: angiography, digital subtraction cerebral arteriovenous malformations hemorrhage time factors
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The main goal of AVM treatment by modern endovascular techniques, microsurgery, and radiosurgery is the prevention of ICH. Newly diagnosed patients are usually advised to undergo treatment of the AVM if the anticipated morbidity rate is low. This management approach assumes that the risk of bleeding over a patients lifetime is substantial. However, AVM patients constitute a heterogeneous population with respect to their risk of hemorrhage. Therefore, risk predictors of hemorrhage for untreated AVMs are needed to facilitate better clinical decision making. Furthermore, risk predictors of hemorrhage are considered in the treatment choice. Patients with AVMs of low hemorrhage risk are ideal candidates for radiosurgery, while those at high risk for hemorrhage should undergo removal of the AVM.8
Characteristics that may indicate an increased risk of hemorrhage from AVMs include small nidus size,914 deep-seated location,1517 presence of arterial aneurysms,15,17,18 single draining vein,11,12,19 and impaired venous drainage.11,16,20 Hemodynamic risk factors are also thought to play important roles in hemorrhage associated with AVMs, and high-perfusion arterial pressure may represent an especially high risk factor.913,21
Current advances in the field of electronics have facilitated the development and application of a new technology known as digital imaging. Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) allows not only anatomic imaging of the central nervous system but also evaluation of the hemodynamics by assessing rapidly acquired quantitative data.2224 In the present study we measured the mean transit time (MTT) of feeding arteries and draining veins in AVMs using time-density curves acquired by DSA, and we evaluated the correlation between hemorrhage and hemodynamic factors.
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The morphological features we evaluated were the number of draining veins and the nidal volume (volume=
xxxyxz/6, where x, y, and z represent the diameter of each axis on MRI).25 All patients with hemorrhage underwent MRI
1 month after the event. This interval was thought to be sufficient to minimize possible confounding contributions from hemorrhage and edema to measurements of AVM nidus volume. Patients with severe stenosis of the draining vein and those with AVM-associated aneurysms (defined as flow-related and/or flow-unrelated feeding artery aneurysms and/or intranidal aneurysms) were excluded from this study.
DSA was performed on an AHD 150G unit (SHIMADZU Medical Systems) with a pixel matrix of 512x512. All patients with hemorrhage underwent repeated angiography
1 month after the event to measure the MTT of the feeding artery and draining vein. This interval was considered to be sufficient to minimize the possible confounding contributions from hemorrhage and hematoma on the intracerebral hemodynamics. The catheter tip was advanced into the internal carotid artery or vertebral artery, 4 to 6 mL of contrast medium was delivered at 1.2 to 2.0 mL/s via an automatic pressure injector, and 30 frames per second were acquired for 10 seconds. We calculated the time-density curve on the lateral plane to compensate for the large amount of fluctuation in background density. The values obtained were fitted to a gamma variate function by the least-squares method26 (Figure, panels B and C), with C(t)=K(t-AT)
xexp[-(t -AT)/ß], where C(t) is the density increment, t is the time after the start of contrast medium injection, K is a constant scale factor,
and ß are fit coefficients, and AT is the time of arrival of the contrast medium.
and ß were determined by the least-squares method to best fit the change in the time-density curve for each region of interest (ROI). Each ROI had a diameter of 2 pixels. ROIs were drawn on the feeding artery and on the draining vein as close as possible to the nidus without superimposition of adjacent arteries and veins (Figure, panel A). For each ROI, the value of the hemodynamic parameter was calculated with the use of these 2 coefficients. The calculated hemodynamic parameters included the MTT, defined as the difference between the time of arrival of contrast medium and the center of gravity of the area under the time-density curve (Figure, panels B and C). In each case, the MTT of the feeding and draining vessels was measured, and the ratio of the MTT of the draining vein to the feeding artery was calculated. If the AVM had multiple feeding and/or draining vessels, ROIs were drawn on each vessel, and MTTs were measured individually. The average MTT of multiple feeding arteries was obtained and defined as the MTT of the feeding arteries. In patients whose AVM had multiple draining veins, the longest MTT of the drainers was defined as the MTT of the draining veins because we posited that the longest MTT of the drainers reflects impaired venous drainage for AVMs with multiple draining vessels.
|
The diameter of the feeding and draining vessels was measured on the DSA image. The occipitofrontal diameter was determined on the CT and on the lateral plane of the DSA image, and the reduction rate was calculated (reduction rate=A/B, where A is the occipitofrontal diameter on the lateral plane of the DSA and B is the occipitofrontal diameter on the CT). The diameter of feeding and draining vessels at the ROIs was measured on the DSA images. To obtain the actual diameter of these vessels, the diameter on the DSA image was divided by the reduction rate.
The study population (n=30) was grouped into patients with (n=22) and without hemorrhage (n=8), patients with single (n=12) and multiple draining veins (n=18), and patients with small (<3 cm) (n=14) and medium or large (
3 cm) AVMs (n=16). The groups were compared with respect to the MTT of the feeding and draining vessels, and the ratio of the MTT of drainers to feeders was recorded.
All analyses were performed by a clinician blinded to the patients history, mode of presentation, and clinical course. The statistical methods employed were Students t test and Welchs t test for unpaired data. If the distribution of 2 mother groups was the same, Students t test was used. If it was different, Welchs t test was applied. Differences in the distribution of the 2 mother groups were examined by the F test. A probability value of <0.05 was considered significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
There is currently no consensus on the relationship between draining vein pressure (DVP) and the risk for hemorrhage. Nornes and Grip28 reported that average DVP tended to be higher in AVM patients with hemorrhage than in those without hemorrhage; however, their sample was small, and their results were inconclusive. Kader et al9 found no difference in DVP between ruptured and unruptured AVMs. More recently, Miyasaka et al12 demonstrated that the pressure in draining as well as feeding vessels was significantly higher in AVMs with than without hemorrhage. Furthermore, in their study population, DVP was inversely related to the number of draining veins and the size of the AVMs. DVP elevation may be attributable to the presence of a central venous drainage pattern, stenotic or occlusive involvement of the venous drainage system, or a low number of draining veins.10,11,15,16
We found that in hemorrhagic AVMs the MTT of feeding arteries was significantly shorter than in nonhemorrhagic AVMs, while the MTT of draining vessels was not significantly different (Table 4). Our findings support the hypothesis that high pressure in the feeding arteries may lead to AVM rupture9,13,21 because vascular pressure is directly proportional to flow velocity, which, in turn, is inversely proportional to MTT.23 However, many factors, including the vessel diameter, viscoelastic properties of the vessel wall, and downstream resistance, affect the relationship between pressure and velocity. Further studies are needed to provide direct experimental confirmation of this relationship. Norris et al29 suggested that AVMs in which contrast medium took longer to reach maximum concentration in the feeders were more likely to rupture. On the other hand, Matsumoto et al23 reported that the MTT of feeders tended to be shorter in hemorrhagic than in nonhemorrhagic AVMs. Likewise, we found that the MTT of feeders was significantly shorter in hemorrhagic than in nonhemorrhagic AVMs (Table 4). Spetzler et al13 demonstrated that the feeding artery pressure was higher in small AVMs and that they had a high incidence of rupture. Similarly, in our study the ruptured AVMs tended to be small; however, we found no significant correlation between nidus size and the incidence of hemorrhage (Table 1). In small AVMs, the MTT of feeders and drainers was significantly shorter than in the larger AVMs (Table 2), and the vessel diameter tended to be narrower; the difference was not significant, however. Nonetheless, the narrower vessel diameters may have exerted an influence on MTT. If vascular pressure is indeed directly proportional to flow velocity,23 pressure in the feeding and draining vessels is higher in small than in large AVMs.
In our unruptured AVMs, the MTT ratio of drainers to feeders was close to 1 (Table 4), suggesting equivalent nidal inflow and outflow. In hemorrhagic AVMs, on the other hand, nidal inflow may exceed outflow because of impediments in the draining system. While the relationship between DVP and the MTT ratio of drainers to feeders remains unclear, disequilibrium in nidal inflow and outflow may lead to drainage pressure elevation. Excess blood may be redistributed into the fragile plexiform vessels around the nidus, and drainage pressure elevation and blood flow redistribution may result in hemodynamic overload and increase the risk for rupture.20 However, in our study the MTT ratio of draining to feeding vessels was not significantly different between small and larger AVMs. While excess nidal inflow may lead to hemorrhage, this is not consistent with findings that small AVMs have a higher rate of hemorrhage.914 The MTT ratio of drainers to feeders in our small and larger AVMs was 1.62 and 1.46, respectively, and the absence of a significant difference may be attributable to the small size of our study population. Because there was no significant difference with respect to the number of draining veins we observed in small and larger AVMs, we posit that the increased risk for hemorrhage in smaller AVMs may not be merely a reflection of the number of drainers. Although there was no statistical difference in the number of venous draining vessels in large and small AVMs in this study, this sample size was small, and the trend we observed was toward more draining veins in larger AVMs.
Our results suggest that fast nidal inflow and a high MTT ratio of drainers to feeders are risk factors for hemorrhage in patients with AVMs. As shown in Table 4, fast nidal inflow, evidenced by the significantly shorter feeding artery MTT in 22 hemorrhagic AVMs, resulted in a trend toward increased venous drainage times, manifested by the longer MTT in single than multiple drainers (Table 3). Of the 2 risk factors for hemorrhage, we posit that a high MTT ratio of drainers to feeders is the most reliable. The MTT obtained from time-density curves tends to be affected by the contrast medium injection site, injection rate, and injection volume. In addition, the degree of atherosclerosis, patients cardiopulmonary functions, total blood volume, and blood viscosity are factors that must be considered. Therefore, the MTTs of feeders and drainers are relative parameters that vary among patients. On the other hand, because the ratio of drainers to feeders is not strongly affected by patient characteristics, we suggest that comparative assessments are possible. The feeder-to-drainer ratio is not an independent risk factor but a numerical expression of the degree of mismatch between nidal inflow and outflow, which are affected by nidus size, number and stenotic status of drainers, and drainage pathway.
The increased availability and use of diagnostic tools have raised the number of incidentally detected AVMs and the dilemma of whether and how to treat them. While in many cases these decisions are made empirically, there is a need for objective criteria to guide the patient and the physician. Although the Spetzler-Martin grading system30 has already proved its usefulness, it does not take into account angioarchitectonic features that may put individual patients at disproportionate risk for neurological deficits from a hemorrhage. We suggest that objective MTT measurements may be of significant benefit in deciding the appropriate management of unruptured AVMs. Given the dynamic nature of AVMs, serial angiograms are needed to ensure that the transit time characteristics of the particular AVM remain stable.
The results of our study are subject to certain limitations. First, because the study population was small, we cannot draw strong conclusions regarding risk factors for hemorrhage in patients with AVM. Second, because AVMs are compartmentalized structures, the mismatch between arterial and venous flow and the consequent pressure changes determine hemorrhage risk on a case-by-case basis. Studies of the MTT performed in combination with superselective angiography are under way. In subsequent investigations, we will measure feeding artery pressure with an intracranial microcatheter and will analyze the correlation between feeding artery MTT and pressure. Furthermore, AVMs with drainage exclusively into the deep venous system or into severely stenotic vessels are known to have a high incidence of rupture.8,10,17,18,20 We are performing studies to clarify the relationship between the flow velocity in deep or stenotic draining vessels and the risk of AVM rupture. Lastly, because MTT tends to be reflective of the aforementioned individual clinical characteristics, care must be exercised when conclusions are drawn on groups of patients with AVM.
Conclusion
We used DSA time-density curves to measure the MTT of feeders and drainers in patients with AVMs. Our finding that the MTT ratio of draining to feeding vessels was significantly higher in ruptured than in unruptured AVMs suggests disequilibrium between nidal inflow and outflow. We posit that this mismatch results in drainage pressure elevation and an increased risk for AVM rupture.
Received January 29, 2003; revision received June 3, 2003; accepted June 18, 2003.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. R. Hadizadeh, M. von Falkenhausen, J. Gieseke, B. Meyer, H. Urbach, R. Hoogeveen, H. H. Schild, and W. A. Willinek Cerebral Arteriovenous Malformation: Spetzler-Martin Classification at Subsecond-Temporal-Resolution Four-dimensional MR Angiography Compared with That at DSA Radiology, December 1, 2007; 246(1): 205 - 213. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Stroke Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2003 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |